Menupedia is an independent reference. Not affiliated with any restaurant listed. Menu data reviewed May 2026 — confirm with the official source before ordering.
Menupedia
Fine Dining · American

Noble Cellar Menu Prices 2026: Full List, Small Plates & Best Value

Noble Cellar is Syracuse's most celebrated fine dining destination, occupying a beautifully converted 19th-century Methodist church at 304 E Onondaga St. The restaurant earned CNY Reader's Choice Best Restaurant honors in both 2024 and 2025, along with Wine Spectator's Award of Excellence and the prestigious DiRōNA Award, distinguishing it as one of Upstate New York's premier tables.

Award-winning fine diningHistoric church settingWine Spectator Award of Excellence
Jump to full menu Cheapest items
Sample · $$$

Signature items

Angus Reserve NY Strip$51
Pork Chop$43
Steak Tartar$26
Cheese Plate$24
Jump to: Quick answers Full menu Cheapest items Most popular Compare prices About FAQ
Quick answers

What to order — at a glance

Cheapest item
Seasonal Ice Creams & Sorbets from $4
Most popular
Steak Tartar $26

A signature small plate, consistently praised in reviews

Best value small plate
Leaves, Flowers & Herbs Salad $12
Signature entree
Angus Reserve NY Strip $51
Full menu with prices

Noble Cellar full menu and current prices

Prices sourced from Noble Cellar's official menu as of 2026. Confirm current prices at your visit or via noble-cellar.com.
Small Plates6 itemsSoups & Salads4 itemsDinner Entrees8 itemsLunch Salads3 itemsLunch Entrees6 itemsSides4 itemsDesserts4 itemsCafé & Wine6 items
Budget picks

Cheapest items on the Noble Cellar menu

  1. 1Seasonal Ice Creams & SorbetsPer scoop$4
  2. 2Homemade Potato Chips$7
  3. 3Haley's Pasta Salad$7
  4. 4Side Salad$8
  5. 5Espresso$8
  6. 6Americano$8
  7. 7Mac & Cheese$9
  8. 8Cardamaro Vino Amaro$10
  9. 9Leaves, Flowers & Herbs Salad$12
  10. 10French Onion Soup$14
Price comparison

Dinner entrees: price at a glance

Noble Cellar's dinner entrees range from vegetarian options to premium steaks — here's how they line up by price.

ItemCategoryPrice
"Chicken" Fried Oyster MushroomsVegetarian$34
Farmer's Market 1/2 ChickenPoultry$38
Duck Breast "Steak Frites"Duck$39
Summer FlounderSeafood$40
Grilled SwordfishSeafood$42
Pork ChopPork$43
Flat IronSteak$48
Angus Reserve NY StripSteak$51
Price comparison

How Noble Cellar prices compare to fine dining competitors

Like-for-like comparison of common fine dining categories across Upstate NY and national upscale chains.

CategoryNoble CellarThe Capital GrilleMorton's SteakhouseBonefish Grill
Cheapest small plate/app$12$16$18$10
Signature steak entree$51$65+$75+$35
Seafood entree$40–$42$45+$55+$28–$38
Dessert$16$14–$18$14–$16$8–$10
Wine by the glass$16+$18+$20+$10–$14
About

About Noble Cellar

Noble Cellar opened at 304 E Onondaga St in downtown Syracuse, NY, inside a beautifully repurposed 19th-century Methodist church. The original stained glass windows remain intact, casting colorful light across the dining room and giving the space a warmth and grandeur that is rare in Central New York. Despite the formal surroundings, the restaurant's philosophy is rooted in approachable hospitality — fine dining without pretension.

The kitchen focuses on seasonal American cuisine, sourcing from local and regional farms and fisheries. The menu changes to reflect what's best at the market, from summer flounder and swordfish to farmer's market chicken and rhubarb cake. Noble Cellar also maintains one of the most celebrated wine programs in Upstate New York, earning Wine Spectator's Award of Excellence in both 2024 and 2025 and holding bottles and selections from acclaimed producers worldwide.

In 2024 and again in 2025, Noble Cellar was named Best Restaurant by CNY Reader's Choice, and in 2025 it received the DiRōNA Award — Distinguished Restaurants of North America — a recognition shared by only the top tier of North American dining establishments. For Syracusans and visitors alike, Noble Cellar represents a rare opportunity to experience world-class dining without leaving Upstate New York.

1location (Syracuse, NY)
2024CNY Best Restaurant
$$$price range

Ready to visit Noble Cellar?

Reservations are recommended. Book your table through Resy and confirm current menu and hours on the official website.

Reserve a table at Noble Cellar
FAQ

Frequently asked questions

Where is Noble Cellar located?

Noble Cellar is located at 304 E Onondaga St, Syracuse, NY 13202, in a beautifully restored historic Methodist church in downtown Syracuse. Street parking is available nearby, and the restaurant is wheelchair accessible.

What are Noble Cellar's hours?

Noble Cellar serves lunch Monday through Friday from 11:30 AM to 2:00 PM. Dinner service runs Tuesday through Thursday from 5:00 PM to 9:00 PM and Friday through Saturday from 5:00 PM to 9:30 PM. The restaurant is closed Sundays and Mondays for dinner.

How much does dinner at Noble Cellar cost?

Dinner entrees range from $34 for the vegetarian Fried Oyster Mushrooms to $51 for the Angus Reserve NY Strip. Small plates start around $17–$26, and desserts are $16. A typical dinner for two with wine will generally run $150–$200 before tax and tip.

Does Noble Cellar have a full bar?

Noble Cellar does not have a full liquor bar due to a local ordinance restricting spirits service within 500 feet of churches. However, the restaurant maintains an award-winning wine program — Wine Spectator recognized it with the Award of Excellence in both 2024 and 2025 — along with beer and non-alcoholic options.

Does Noble Cellar take reservations?

Yes, reservations are strongly recommended and can be made through Resy at resy.com. Walk-ins may be accommodated based on availability, but given the restaurant's popularity and limited seating, booking ahead is advisable, especially on weekends.

What awards has Noble Cellar won?

Noble Cellar has received significant recognition: CNY Reader's Choice Best Restaurant for 2024 and 2025, Wine Spectator's Award of Excellence for 2024 and 2025, and the prestigious DiRōNA Award (Distinguished Restaurants of North America) in 2025. These honors place it among the top fine dining establishments in Upstate New York.

Does Noble Cellar have vegetarian options?

Yes. Noble Cellar offers several vegetarian dishes, including Smoked Baby Sweet Potatoes ($17), Beet & Berries ($21), Cheese Plate ($24), the Leaves, Flowers & Herbs salad ($12), and the fan-favorite "Chicken" Fried Oyster Mushrooms entree ($34). Desserts including panna cotta, sweet potato pie, and rhubarb cake are also vegetarian-friendly.

What is the dress code at Noble Cellar?

Noble Cellar is a fine dining establishment and guests are encouraged to dress accordingly. Business casual to smart casual attire is appropriate; the intimate church setting and award-winning service create an elevated atmosphere that warrants dressing up slightly for the occasion.

Can Noble Cellar accommodate dietary restrictions?

Noble Cellar's seasonally driven kitchen can accommodate many dietary needs, including gluten-free options. For severe allergies or specific dietary restrictions, it's best to contact the restaurant directly at greetings@noble-cellar.com or call (315) 303-2003 before your visit so the kitchen can plan accordingly.