Sweet Mandy B's Chicago Menu & Prices 2026: Cupcakes, Cakes & More

Sweet Mandy B's cupcakes are priced at $1.10 each for mini, regular, and jumbo sizes -- one of the most affordable cupcake prices in Chicago for a from-scratch, award-winning bakery. Flavors include Yellow, Devil's Food, Red Velvet, Confetti, Cookie Monster, Snickerdoodle, Banana, Carrot, Chocolate Peanut Butter, Vegan Vanilla, and Vegan Chocolate. Confirm daily availability by phone at (773) 244-1174 (Lincoln Park) or (312) 255-1632 (Streeterville).

Sweet Mandy B's has two Chicago locations. The original Lincoln Park bakery is at 1208 W Webster Ave, Chicago IL 60614 (phone: (773) 244-1174), open Mon-Fri 9am-7pm, Sat 8am-8pm, Sun 9am-6pm. The Streeterville location is at 254 E Ontario St, Chicago IL 60611 (phone: (312) 255-1632), open daily 9am-6pm.

Yes. Sweet Mandy B's specializes in custom celebration cakes and wedding cakes. Standard custom cakes require 5-7 days' notice; tiered or wedding cakes may require several weeks. Cakes are available in round sizes (6", 9", 12") in 2 or 3 layers, and in half-sheet or full-sheet formats. Prices range from $16 (6" 2-layer) to $74 (full-sheet 1-layer). Credit card is required at the time of ordering. Contact them directly for wedding cake consultations.

Sweet Mandy B's daily cupcake flavors include Yellow/Vanilla, Chocolate/Chocolate, Red Velvet, Confetti, Cookie Monster, Snickerdoodle, Banana, Carrot, Chocolate Peanut Butter, Vegan Vanilla, and Vegan Chocolate. Seasonal flavors like Strawberry and Pumpkin appear periodically. Not all flavors are available every day -- call ahead or check their daily menu online to confirm what's available before visiting.

Yes. Sweet Mandy B's offers Vegan Vanilla and Vegan Chocolate cupcakes, both priced at $1.10 each. For other items, check with the bakery directly as ingredient compositions can vary. Their Flourless Chocolate Cake is naturally gluten-free (individual at $2.25, full 9" at $18) and a popular option for guests with gluten sensitivity, though it is not vegan.

Yes. Sweet Mandy B's accepts same-day orders through their online ordering system (powered by Toast Tab), accessible via their official website at sweetmandybs.com. Future and custom orders can be placed by phone. Custom cakes require advance notice -- typically 5-7 days minimum. The bakery also offers pickup and delivery options. Credit card is required at time of ordering; cash is not accepted.

Sweet Mandy B's pies are available in two sizes: 6-inch for $7.00 and 9-inch for $20.00. Flavors include Apple, Cherry Apple, Blueberry Apple, Banana Cream, Coconut Cream, Chocolate Cream, Key Lime, Pecan, Turtle, Lemon Chiffon, Peanut Butter Chiffon, and a Seasonal Berry pie. Not all flavors are available every day -- call ahead to confirm.

The Lincoln Park location (1208 W Webster Ave) is open Monday-Friday 9am-7pm, Saturday 8am-8pm, Sunday 9am-6pm. The Streeterville location (254 E Ontario St) is open daily 9am-6pm. Hours may vary on holidays -- confirm via the official website or by calling ahead before a special trip.

Sweet Mandy B's has been a Lincoln Park neighborhood institution since 2002 and is consistently named among Chicago's best cupcakes. The bakery is known for its from-scratch buttercream frosting, fresh daily baking, and a wide range of flavors including unique options like Cookie Monster, Snickerdoodle, and seasonal specialties. At $1.10 per cupcake, they remain one of the most affordable high-quality cupcakes in the city. The bakery has been featured in numerous Chicago food guides and awarded best cupcake honors by local publications.