Sheetz Menu Prices 2026: MTO Subs, Burgers & Coffee

A 6-inch Made-To-Order sub is about $6.49 and a 12-inch (footlong) about $9.49 as of May 2026. Both come with unlimited free toppings — you build the whole thing (meat, cheese, bread, sauces, veggies) on the touchscreen kiosk. Specialty subs like the Italian (~$7.99) and the cult-favorite Chicken Strip Sub (~$8.49) cost a bit more. At those prices with unlimited toppings, Sheetz MTO subs are one of the best food values in the convenience-store world and competitive with dedicated sub shops.

MTO stands for 'Made-To-Order' — Sheetz's signature food program. Instead of grabbing pre-packaged food, you order on a touchscreen kiosk, customize every ingredient, and the kitchen makes it fresh while you wait. The MTO menu covers subs, burgers, wraps, quesadillas, breakfast sandwiches (Shmuffins), fries and more — all available 24 hours a day. The kiosk-ordering, made-fresh model is exactly what separates Sheetz from a normal gas station and why fans treat it as a restaurant, not just a convenience store.

Yes — most Sheetz locations are open 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, and the full Made-To-Order food and coffee menus are available around the clock. You can order a fresh sub, burger, quesadilla or Shmuffin breakfast sandwich at 3am just as easily as at noon. The 24/7 hot, made-fresh food is a huge part of the brand's appeal, especially for road-trippers, third-shift workers and late-night crowds across its Mid-Atlantic footprint.

These are two of Sheetz's signature 'Sh-' branded items. A Shmuffin (~$4.49) is Sheetz's breakfast sandwich — egg, cheese and meat on an English muffin, biscuit or croissant, available 24/7. A Shmix (~$4.49) is Sheetz's hand-spun milkshake, with a wide range of flavors and mix-ins you select on the kiosk. There's also a Frozen Shmix (blended frozen coffee). The playful 'Sh-' naming is part of the Sheetz brand personality, and both items have devoted followings.

Yes — Sheetz runs a full Sheetz Bros. Coffeez espresso and coffee program that's a genuine selling point, not an afterthought. Beyond brewed coffee (~$1.99), you can order made-to-order lattes (~$3.99), cappuccinos (~$3.79), cold brew (~$3.99) and flavored iced coffees on the kiosk, hot or iced, 24/7. The coffee is priced well below dedicated coffee chains, and many regulars use Sheetz as their daily coffee stop the way others use Dunkin or Starbucks.

The MTO sub (6" $6.49 / 12" $9.49) with unlimited toppings is the iconic order and best value. The Chicken Strip Sub (~$8.49) is a famous cult favorite. For a quick meal, the MTO Burger (~$5.99) or MTO Quesadilla (~$6.99) are strong picks, and Boom Boom Shrimp (~$6.99) is a popular shareable. Don't skip the Shmix milkshake (~$4.49) or a made-to-order latte (~$3.99). For breakfast, the Shmuffin Combo (~$6.49) is the go-to, any hour.

Sheetz operates around 700 locations as of 2026, concentrated in Pennsylvania, Maryland, Virginia, West Virginia, Ohio, North Carolina and surrounding states. The company is family-owned and headquartered in Altoona, Pennsylvania, where it was founded in 1952. Sheetz is fiercely regional — it inspires strong loyalty in its home territory (and a friendly rivalry with Wawa, the other beloved Mid-Atlantic convenience chain) — and continues to expand southward into the Carolinas. If you're outside the Mid-Atlantic and Appalachian region, there likely isn't a Sheetz near you yet.

Yes — because the MTO subs, wraps and quesadillas are fully build-your-own, you can make many of them vegetarian. Meatless menu items include Fries ($2.99), Mozzarella Sticks ($4.49), Mac & Cheese Bites ($3.99), Onion Rings ($3.49), soft pretzels, plus the entire coffee, Shmix shake ($4.49), smoothie and soft-serve lineup. A cheese-and-veggie MTO sub or quesadilla is an easy vegetarian build. There's no dedicated plant-based protein on the standard menu as of 2026, so confirm options on the kiosk.