Marble Slab Creamery Menu Prices 2026: Full List & Best Value

Yes — Marble Slab Creamery calls them "Always Free Mix-Ins." Every order of ice cream includes mix-ins at no extra charge. You can choose fruits like strawberries and bananas, nuts like almonds and pecans, candies like M&Ms and gummy bears, and baked pieces like brownie chunks and Oreo crumbles. The number of mix-ins you can add scales with the size you order.

The smallest regular size — called "Like It" — averages around $5.49 nationally as of 2026. Kids' scoops are available for around $3.99. Because Marble Slab is a franchise chain, prices vary by location; the figures here are national averages, so check with your local store for exact pricing.

Both chains mix ice cream on a frozen stone surface and include mix-ins, making them direct competitors. The key differences: Marble Slab was founded in 1983 and emphasizes small-batch homemade ice cream made fresh daily at each store. Cold Stone, founded in 1988, is somewhat larger (1,500+ U.S. locations vs. Marble Slab's 300+). Marble Slab often co-locates with Great American Cookies (same parent company, FAT Brands), which Cold Stone does not. Prices are comparable.

Yes. Marble Slab is well-known for custom ice cream cakes available in multiple sizes: 6-inch rounds (serves 6–8, ~$28.99), 8-inch rounds (serves 10–12, ~$38.99), quarter-sheet, and half-sheet options for larger parties. You can choose any ice cream flavors and mix-ins for the filling, and stores can add custom decoration. It's best to order at least 48 hours in advance, especially for intricate designs.

Marble Slab's core menu is dairy-based, and the chain does not widely advertise a dairy-free ice cream base as of 2026. However, many mix-ins — like fruits, nuts, and some candies — are naturally dairy-free. If you have specific dietary needs, contact your local store directly, as offerings vary by franchisee and some locations may carry non-dairy sorbets or other alternatives.

Marble Slab Creamery offers a standing roster of core flavors available year-round — like Sweet Cream, Cake Batter, Mint Chocolate Chip, and Strawberry — plus a rotating lineup of seasonal limited-time flavors that typically change quarterly. Popular seasonal examples include Pumpkin Pie in fall and Peppermint Bark around the holidays. The exact seasonal selection depends on your location.

Marble Slab Creamery participates in the FAT Brands loyalty program, which can be accessed via the Marble Slab mobile app. Members earn points on qualifying purchases that can be redeemed for free ice cream, cakes, or other rewards. The app also features mobile ordering, exclusive offers, and early access to new flavor announcements.

Yes. The shake menu includes signature options like Cotton Candy, Cookies 'N Cream, and Strawberry shakes, plus a "Create-Your-Own" shake where you pick any ice cream and mix-ins. Fruit smoothies are available at participating locations. Shakes average around $7.99 at most stores.

Each Marble Slab Creamery location makes its ice cream in-house in small batches daily using fresh dairy and quality ingredients — it is not shipped in from a central plant. When you order, a portion of ice cream is placed on a granite slab chilled to approximately 16°F. The employee then adds your chosen mix-ins and uses two metal paddles to fold and blend everything together until the mix-ins are fully incorporated into the ice cream before serving.