Andy's Frozen Custard Menu & Prices 2026: Concretes, Sundaes & More

Frozen custard is a richer, denser cousin of ice cream. The key difference is the egg yolk content: the FDA requires frozen custard to contain at least 1.4% egg yolk by weight, which gives it a significantly creamier, denser texture than standard ice cream. Frozen custard is also churned at a slower speed and with less air incorporated (a property called overrun), making it heavier and more dense per ounce than most commercial ice cream. Andy's makes theirs fresh throughout the day, so it's served warmer and softer than ice cream pulled from a deep freezer.

A concrete is Andy's signature item: dense frozen custard blended (not just topped) with mix-ins like Oreos, brownie pieces, fresh fruit, candy bars, caramel, fudge, or nuts. The custard and mix-ins are blended so thoroughly that the treat can famously be held upside-down without spilling. The concrete is similar in concept to Culver's Concrete Mixer or Freddy's Concrete. You pick a custard base (vanilla or chocolate) and up to several mix-ins, and the crew blends it to order in front of you.

Andy's does not publish a national price list online; prices vary by location and market. Based on widely-reported 2025-2026 consumer pricing, concretes typically run $5–$8 depending on size (small, medium, large) and the number of mix-ins. Sundaes tend to be in the $5–$7 range, cones and dishes from $3–$6, and shakes/malts from $5–$7. Confirm with your local Andy's store or via a food-delivery app for exact current pricing.

Andy's Frozen Custard operates locations primarily across the Midwest and South, including Missouri (including the original Osage Beach location and many Kansas City- and Springfield-area stores), Kansas, Oklahoma, Texas (Dallas-Fort Worth metro and other markets), Arkansas, Tennessee, and additional states. The chain has grown steadily since 1986 and continues to expand. Use the store locator on andysfrozencustard.com to find the closest location to you.

Andy's Frozen Custard was founded in 1986 in Osage Beach, Missouri — a resort town in the Lake of the Ozarks region. The chain's slogan ('40 years sweet since '86') and its family ownership roots are central to its brand identity. It has grown from a single Missouri stand into a multi-state regional chain recognized as one of the premier frozen-custard destinations in the Midwest.

Yes — rotating seasonal flavors are a hallmark of Andy's. Common seasonal returns include Peach custard in summer, Strawberry Shortcake and Blackberry in spring/summer (part of the 'Battle of the Berries' seasonal promotion), Pumpkin Spice in fall, and Peppermint around the holidays. Many locations also run a 'Custard of the Day' — a fresh specialty flavor made in limited batches. Check your local store or the Andy's app/social media for the current seasonal lineup.

All three chains serve Wisconsin-style frozen custard as their centerpiece dessert, and all offer signature concrete-style blended mixers. The differences are in focus and format: Culver's is a full-service burger-and-custard chain (ButterBurgers alongside Concrete Mixers); Freddy's similarly pairs flat-top steakburgers with frozen custard concretes. Andy's is dessert-only — its entire menu revolves around custard, making the custard itself the primary focus rather than an add-on to a burger meal. Andy's is also more regionally concentrated in Missouri, Kansas, Oklahoma, and Texas vs. Culver's Midwest-wide and Freddy's broader expansion.

Most Andy's locations are open year-round, though hours may be reduced in winter months depending on the market. Some original or seasonal locations (particularly in resort areas like the Lake of the Ozarks) may operate on a seasonal schedule. Check your specific location on the official Andy's store locator or call ahead during colder months. The chain's core markets (Kansas City, Springfield, Tulsa, DFW) typically maintain full-year operations.

Andy's Frozen Custard's core menu is custard-based, meaning all standard items contain dairy and egg. As of mid-2026, Andy's does not offer a certified dairy-free or vegan frozen custard option nationally. Guests with dairy allergies or vegan dietary needs should contact their local location to ask about any test items or accommodation options, as offerings can vary. For allergen details, call your nearest Andy's directly or check the official website.