Cold Stone Creamery Menu 2026: Creations, Shakes & Ice Cream Cakes

Cold Stone Creamery prices vary significantly by franchise location. A Like It (5 oz) typically runs $5–$7, a Love It (8 oz) around $6–$9, and a Gotta Have It (12 oz) around $8–$11 depending on the market and mix-ins chosen. Urban locations and higher-cost markets (California, New York, Hawaii) trend higher. Cold Stone does not publish a national price list — check your local store or order through the Cold Stone app for current pricing.

Cold Stone's most-ordered Signature Creations are Peanut Butter Cup Perfection (chocolate ice cream, Reese's Peanut Butter Cups, peanut butter, fudge), Birthday Cake Remix (birthday cake ice cream, brownie, rainbow sprinkles, whipped topping), and Founders Favorite (sweet cream ice cream, brownie, caramel, pecans, fudge). These three consistently top Cold Stone's own rankings and appear in most national promotions.

Birthday Cake Remix is one of Cold Stone's top Signature Creations: birthday cake flavored ice cream folded with brownie pieces, rainbow sprinkles, and whipped topping on the frozen stone. It is consistently ranked among the chain's top three sellers. You can order it in Like It, Love It, or Gotta Have It sizes.

Peanut Butter Cup Perfection is Cold Stone's most popular peanut butter Creation: chocolate ice cream blended with Reese's Peanut Butter Cups, peanut butter, and hot fudge on the frozen granite stone. Available in all three sizes. It is a permanent menu item across most U.S. locations.

Cold Stone offers Mango Sorbet and Strawberry Banana Sorbet as dairy-free options at most locations, both of which can be made vegan by choosing compatible mix-ins. However, Cold Stone's kitchen is not dairy-free, and cross-contact with dairy is likely. The chain does not certify any items as vegan. Availability of sorbet flavors varies by location — confirm with your store. People with severe dairy allergies should contact the store directly before ordering.

Cold Stone uses three size names instead of small/medium/large: Like It is 5 oz (smallest, good for kids or light servings), Love It is 8 oz (most popular size, fits 2-3 mix-ins well), and Gotta Have It is 12 oz (largest single-serve, often split between two people). Each size can be served in a cup, waffle cone, or waffle bowl — cone and bowl upgrades carry an additional charge at most locations.

Cold Stone ice cream cake pricing varies by size and location. A 6-inch round cake (serves 6-8) typically runs $30–$45, and a 10-inch round cake (serves 12-14) typically runs $50–$70. Prices are not published nationally; contact your local store or order online through the Cold Stone website. Cakes generally require 24-48 hours advance notice. Custom decorations may add to the cost.

Cold Stone Creamery operates more than 1,500 locations in the United States and additional international locations in over 25 countries. Nearly all are independently owned franchises. Use the store locator on coldstonecreamery.com to find the nearest store and confirm current hours.

According to Cold Stone's own promotion data, the top mix-ins by order frequency are Reese's Peanut Butter Cups, Oreo cookie pieces, brownie pieces, hot fudge, and caramel. Rainbow sprinkles are the top choice for the birthday cake flavors. For a build-your-own starting point: sweet cream + brownie + caramel + pecans replicates the Founders Favorite; chocolate + peanut butter + Reese's + fudge replicates Peanut Butter Cup Perfection.