Burgatory Menu 2026: Gourmet Burgers, Milkshakes & Pittsburgh's Best Bar Burgers

Burgatory is a Pittsburgh-based elevated burger bar — a step above a standard fast-casual burger spot. It's a full sit-down bar and grill known for creative gourmet burgers with bold toppings, craft and spiked milkshakes, hand-cut fries, and a beer-forward bar program. The vibe is casual but the food is thoughtfully sourced and prepared. It operates several locations across the Pittsburgh metro area.

Yes. Burgatory has a full bar program centered on craft beer — usually 20+ local and regional drafts — alongside an extensive canned and bottled beer list, wines, and cocktails. One of the brand's most distinctive offerings is the boozy (spiked) milkshake lineup, blending premium spirits into thick milkshakes. Must be 21+ to order alcoholic beverages.

Burgatory's spiked milkshakes are one of the restaurant's signature items — thick, premium milkshakes made with quality ice cream and blended with spirits. Common flavors include bourbon caramel, vodka strawberry, and seasonal specials that rotate with the menu. The spiked shake lineup is available at all Burgatory locations to guests 21 and over. Non-alcoholic versions of most shake flavors are also available.

Yes. Burgatory offers a house-made black bean and quinoa veggie patty as an alternative to the beef patty on any burger, and there are several vegetarian-friendly starters and sides including hand-cut fries, sweet potato fries, onion rings, fried pickles, pretzel bites, mac and cheese bites, and the side salad. The build-your-own menu makes it easy to customize a fully vegetarian meal.

Burgatory operates several locations across the Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania area. As a regional chain rather than a national franchise, the number and exact addresses of locations can change. Visit burgatory.com for the current location list, hours, and reservation information.

As an elevated burger bar with full table service, a craft beer program, and premium ingredients, Burgatory is priced above fast-casual burger chains like Five Guys or Shake Shack but is in the same range as other full-service, craft-burger concepts. Expect to pay more than a fast-food burger but less than a steakhouse. Because Burgatory's website does not publish prices, we recommend checking their current menu in-store or at burgatory.com for up-to-date pricing.

Burgatory uses house-ground beef patties and emphasizes bold, creative topping combinations — think truffle aioli with brie, Pittsburgh-style toppings with coleslaw and fries on the bun, or buffalo sauce with blue cheese crumbles. The kitchen also makes many components in-house including bacon jam, caramelized onions, and specialty aiolis. The burger program is complemented by a rotating craft beer selection, making the overall experience closer to a gastropub than a standard burger joint.

Reservation policies vary by location. Some Burgatory locations accept reservations, while others are walk-in only or first-come-first-served. For the most accurate information, visit burgatory.com or call your nearest location directly. Wait times at popular locations can be significant on weekends.

Based on fan reviews and the restaurant's own reputation, the signature burgers — particularly the Truffle Shuffle (beef, brie, truffle aioli, caramelized onions) and The PGH (Pittsburgh-style with slaw and fries on the bun) — are standout orders. The spiked milkshakes are a must-try for adults. For sides, the Parmesan Truffle Fries and Onion Rings are consistently praised. First-timers are often advised to make it a full experience: a signature burger, shareable side, and a spiked shake or local draft beer.