Which Wich Menu Prices 2026: Full List, Sizes & Best Value

Which Wich uses a unique paper-bag ordering system. When you walk in, you grab a pre-printed bag that lists every protein, bread, and topping option. You circle or check off exactly what you want, hand the bag to the crew, and they build your sub right in front of you. The bag doubles as a way to keep your order completely accurate and as a fun, interactive experience for first-time visitors.

Which Wich offers three sizes: the Little (4"), the Medium (7"), and the Big (10"). The Little is a good snack or kids' option, the Medium is the most popular everyday choice, and the Big is ideal for larger appetites or sharing. Prices step up roughly $3–4 between each size tier.

The Wicked is Which Wich's signature sub and most iconic menu item. It's an Italian-style sandwich loaded with pepperoni, Genoa salami, ham, and capicola, topped with provolone cheese and your choice of vegetables and sauces. Available in all three sizes, the Medium Wicked runs about $10.49 at most locations.

Yes. Which Wich offers a dedicated Veggie category where you build your sub entirely from produce, cheese, and condiment toppings. The Avocado Veggie sub and the Caprese are popular meat-free choices. Many veggie builds can be made vegan by skipping the cheese and mayo-based sauces. The PB&J is also a vegetarian-friendly fan favorite.

Yes — many Which Wich locations serve breakfast during morning hours. The Breakfast Wich lineup includes classic combinations like Bacon, Egg & Cheese; Sausage, Egg & Cheese; Ham, Egg & Cheese; and a Veggie Egg & Cheese. Breakfast Wiches start around $7.49 for a Medium and are available in all three sizes while supplies last.

A Medium (7") Which Wich sub typically ranges from $8.49 for a basic Veggie to about $10.99 for premium Signature Clubs. Little (4") subs start around $4.99–$6.99, making them one of the most affordable fast-casual sandwich options. Big (10") subs run $11.49–$13.99 depending on protein. Prices vary by location, so always confirm at your nearest store.

Which Wich has offered a loyalty program that lets guests earn points on purchases redeemable for free food. The program details and availability may vary by location and time — check the Which Wich website or app for the current rewards structure and sign-up options.

Which Wich sits between Subway and Jersey Mike's in price and positioning. Subway is generally cheaper with 6" subs starting under $6, while Jersey Mike's focuses on freshly sliced deli meats at a slightly higher price point (~$11–$13 for a regular). Which Wich differentiates itself with the paper-bag ordering system, three size options, and a broad breakfast lineup — something both competitors largely lack.

Yes. Which Wich supports online ordering through its website and app, and many locations participate with third-party delivery services including DoorDash, Uber Eats, and Grubhub. Availability depends on your specific location. Online ordering is the fastest way to skip the in-store line, though you'll replicate the paper-bag experience digitally by selecting your toppings on screen.