William Penn Tavern is Lawrenceville's eclectic sports bar, located at 3810 Butler St in Pittsburgh, PA. Best known as the home of the original Kitchen Sink wing sauce, the tavern keeps its kitchen open until midnight every day and offers hearty bar food ranging from hand-formed Angus burgers and South Jersey cheesesteaks to clam strips and Caesar salads.
Signature items
Signature house wing sauce
William Penn Tavern does not publish calorie counts. Prices shown are per third-party menu sources.
| Item | Description | Price |
|---|---|---|
| 10pc Wings | Choice of 14+ sauces | $12.00 |
| South Jersey Cheesesteak | Steak, peppers, onion, mushroom | $11.95 |
| Angus Burger | 1/2 lb USDA beef | $11.00 |
| Grilled Chicken Salad | Romaine, fries, cheese, veggies | $14.75 |
| Mac N Cheese Bites | Fried appetizer | $9.25 |
| Clam Strips | Fried clam strips | $8.75 |
Like-for-like comparison of common bar food categories across Pittsburgh-area and national sports bars.
| Category | William Penn Tavern | Buffalo Wild Wings | Wild Wing Cafe |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10pc Wings | $12.00 | ~$17.00 | ~$15.00 |
| Classic Burger | $11.00 | ~$14.00 | ~$13.00 |
| Basket of Fries | $5.95 | ~$5.49 | ~$5.99 |
| Chicken Tenders | $8.75 | ~$12.99 | ~$11.00 |
| Cheesesteak / Signature Sandwich | $11.95 | ~$14.00 | ~$13.00 |
William Penn Tavern began as a beloved neighborhood fixture in Pittsburgh's Shadyside district before relocating to its current home on Butler Street in Lawrenceville. The move placed the bar in the heart of one of Pittsburgh's most vibrant and growing neighborhoods, where it has continued to serve regulars and newcomers alike as the area's go-to eclectic sports tavern.
The tavern built its identity around wings — specifically, the house-invented Kitchen Sink wing sauce, which mixes a wild combination of flavors and has earned a cult following among Pittsburgh wing enthusiasts. Alongside the Kitchen Sink, the bar offers more than a dozen sauce options, from classic buffalo and honey BBQ to dry jerk, thai chili, and the mysteriously named Bug Juice. The kitchen stays open until midnight seven days a week, making it one of the most reliable late-night food stops in the neighborhood.
Beyond wings, William Penn Tavern offers a full bar-food menu of cheesesteaks, Angus burgers, sandwiches, salads, and appetizers at approachable prices. The space is outfitted with flat-screen TVs throughout, a heated outdoor smoking bar, and a no-fuss atmosphere that makes it equally comfortable for game-day crowds and weeknight regulars.
Find current hours, specials, and up-to-date prices at the official website or call (412) 621-1000.
Visit William Penn Tavern's official siteWilliam Penn Tavern is located at 3810 Butler St in the Lawrenceville neighborhood of Pittsburgh, PA 15201. You can reach them at (412) 621-1000.
The tavern is open Sunday through Wednesday 11:00 am–11:00 pm, and Thursday through Saturday 11:00 am–2:00 am. Notably, the kitchen stays open until midnight every day of the week.
Kitchen Sink is William Penn Tavern's original house-made wing sauce — a bold, layered blend that has become their signature flavor. It's named because it contains, as the saying goes, everything but the kitchen sink. It's one of more than 14 sauce options available on the wing menu.
A 10-piece order of wings is $12.00 with ranch or bleu cheese included. Individual takeout wings are priced at $1.50 each. You can choose from over 14 sauces including Buffalo, Hot, Honey BBQ, Kitchen Sink, Garlic Butter, Dry Cajun, Dry Jerk, Thai Chili, and Bug Juice.
Yes. The South Jersey Cheesesteak ($11.95) is a tavern staple made with steak, green pepper, onion, mushroom, and white American cheese. A South Jersey Chicken Cheesesteak ($11.95) is also available with the same toppings.
Yes. Vegetarian options include a Veggie Burger ($12.00) with lettuce, tomato and onion; a House Salad ($9.75); a Caesar Salad ($10.75); and sides like Basket of Fries ($5.95), Tots ($6.95), and Onion Rings ($6.95).
Yes. The tavern features a heated full outdoor smoking bar area, which provides outdoor seating options year-round.
The most affordable items are the Basket of Fries at $5.95 and individual takeout wings at $1.50 each. Among sides, Tots, Onion Rings, and Cheese Sticks are all $6.95.
William Penn Tavern is a casual sports tavern and generally does not take reservations — seating is first come, first served. For large groups or special events, it's best to call ahead at (412) 621-1000 to confirm their current policy.