Menupedia is an independent reference. Not affiliated with any restaurant listed. Menu data reviewed May 2026 — confirm with the official source before ordering.
Menupedia
Pizza · Sicilian · NYC

Prince Street Pizza Menu 2026: NYC Sicilian Slices & Signature Pies

Prince Street Pizza is one of New York City's most celebrated pizza destinations, built on a single iconic square slice: the Spicy Spring. Sicilian-style dough, spicy vodka sauce, pepperoni, fresh mozzarella, and a caramelized crispy bottom. Below: the full menu breakdown, what to order, how to visit, and everything that makes Prince Street a NYC institution.

NYC SoHo institutionSquare Sicilian slicesSpicy Spring — the signature sliceCelebrity favoriteMultiple NYC locations
Jump to full menu Cheapest items
Sample · $$

Signature items

The Spicy SpringPrice at counter
The Nonna MariaPrice at counter
The PrincePrice at counter
Pepperoni SquarePrice at counter
Whole PiesPrice at counter
Jump to: What to order The Spicy Spring Full menu How to visit About the dough Related NYC pizza FAQ
Quick answers

What to order at Prince Street Pizza

The four most important decisions at the counter, answered upfront.

Must-order
The Spicy Spring

Spicy vodka sauce, pepperoni, mozzarella on crispy Sicilian square. Prince Street's defining slice.

Classic choice
The Nonna Maria

Traditional Sicilian square with tomato sauce and mozzarella — the base that showcases the dough.

Vegetarian pick
The Prince

Margherita-style square slice: tomato, fresh mozzarella, basil, olive oil.

For a group
Whole pies

Round pies available for groups — ask at the counter for current options and sizes.

The signature slice

The Spicy Spring — everything you need to know

The Spicy Spring is what Prince Street Pizza is built on. A square Sicilian slice topped with spicy vodka sauce — creamy, tomato-forward and gently fiery — cupped pepperoni that crisps at the edges during baking, and fresh mozzarella. The dough underneath is thick and airy with a deeply caramelized, crackling-crispy bottom from being baked in a well-oiled pan at high heat.

The combination of textures — crunchy underside, pillowy crumb, creamy-spicy sauce — with the curled, crispy-edged pepperoni on top is what separates it from standard NYC pizza. It's not subtle. The spicy vodka sauce is rich and distinctive, not just a red slice with pepperoni.

Expect a line during lunch and dinner rushes, especially on weekends. Slices typically sell out in the evening — arriving before 6 PM is safer if you specifically want the Spicy Spring.

SicilianStyle
SquareShape
VodkaSauce base
CrispyBottom
Most ordered

Most popular Prince Street Pizza slices

Ranked by popularity and reputation. Prices are shown at the counter — Prince Street does not publish prices online.

  1. 1The Spicy SpringThe signature. Spicy vodka sauce, pepperoni, caramelized crispy bottom.Counter price
  2. 2The Nonna MariaClassic Sicilian square — tomato, mozzarella.Counter price
  3. 3The PrinceMargherita square with basil and olive oil.Counter price
  4. 4Pepperoni SquarePepperoni on the classic Sicilian base.Counter price
  5. 5Seasonal SquareRotating specialty — ask at the counter.Counter price
About prices. Prince Street Pizza does not publish menu prices online. This page omits prices to avoid inaccuracy. Visit in person, check princestreetpizza.com, or call ahead for current pricing. Expect a premium consistent with a SoHo NYC pizza destination.
What's special

Highlights and notable slices

What makes Prince Street's menu stand out in the crowded NYC pizza landscape.

Signature

The Spicy Spring

Spicy vodka sauce, cupped pepperoni, fresh mozzarella on the crispy-bottomed square Sicilian dough. The slice that put Prince Street on the map.

Classic

The Nonna Maria

House tomato sauce and mozzarella on the signature thick Sicilian square — the foundational build.

Rotating

Seasonal Slice

A weekly or seasonal special square — often features local or premium ingredients. Check their Instagram for the latest.

Whole pie

Spicy Vodka Round

The Spicy Spring flavor — spicy vodka sauce, pepperoni, mozzarella — on a full round pie. Great for groups.

Browse the menu

Jump to a category

Prince Street Pizza menu categories.

Signature Square Slices5 itemsRound Pies (Whole)4 itemsExtras & Sides3 items
The full menu

Every Prince Street Pizza menu item

All menu categories and items listed below. Prices are shown at the counter — not published online.

Pricing note. Prince Street Pizza does not publish prices online as of May 2026. Menu items below reflect what is typically available. Confirm current offerings and prices at the counter or via the official website before visiting.
What makes it special

The Sicilian dough — why Prince Street's base is different

Prince Street Pizza's square slices are built on a long-fermented Sicilian dough that creates an open, airy crumb structure similar to high-quality focaccia. The dough is proofed slowly to develop flavor and structure, then baked in a well-oiled steel pan at high heat.

The result is a bottom crust that caramelizes deeply — producing a shatteringly crispy, golden underside — while the interior stays pillowy and light. This two-texture contrast (crunchy base, soft crumb) is the technical foundation of the Prince Street experience, and it's what justifies the lines.

The thick structure also holds up to heavy, rich toppings like the spicy vodka sauce without becoming soggy, which is why the Spicy Spring works.

  • Style: Sicilian (square, pan-baked)
  • Dough: Long-fermented, high-hydration
  • Bake: Oiled steel pan, high heat
  • Bottom: Deeply caramelized, crispy
  • Interior: Airy, open crumb, pillowy
  • Sauce flagship: Spicy vodka (cream-tomato base)
  • Not: Thin-crust NYC round-slice style
Visiting tips

How to get the most out of Prince Street Pizza

Timing

Go early or mid-afternoon

The Spicy Spring and other popular slices sell out — especially on weekends. Arriving before the lunch rush (before noon) or mid-afternoon (2–4 PM on weekdays) typically means shorter lines and more slice options.

What to order

Start with the Spicy Spring

If it's your first visit, the Spicy Spring is the non-negotiable first slice. Add a Nonna Maria to compare the base dough with a traditional tomato-mozzarella build before layering on toppings.

Groups

Order a whole pie for groups

For parties of 3 or more, ordering a whole round pie is more practical than queuing for individual slices. Ask at the counter for available pie options and sizes on the day.

Delivery

Check delivery apps

Prince Street Pizza is available on delivery platforms (availability varies by location). The slice is best fresh, but delivery is a reasonable option if you're not near SoHo.

Locations

Confirm the address

Multiple NYC locations exist. The original SoHo spot is at 27 Prince Street, Manhattan. Confirm hours and address at princestreetpizza.com before making a trip.

Instagram

Check their social for specials

Seasonal specials and limited square slices are often announced on Prince Street's Instagram before appearing at the counter. Worth a follow if you're a regular.

About Prince Street Pizza

From a SoHo corner to a NYC pizza institution.

Prince Street Pizza opened in SoHo, Manhattan and built its reputation on a single slice: the Spicy Spring — a square Sicilian with spicy vodka sauce and pepperoni that became one of the most talked-about pizza items in New York City. The lines outside the Prince Street storefront, running down the sidewalk on weekends, became as iconic as the slice itself.

The success of the original location led to additional NYC outlets and a following that includes a steady stream of celebrity visitors and food-media coverage. Prince Street represents a specific NYC archetype: the single-item slice shop done at a very high level, with a product distinctive enough to sustain reputation across years of competition in one of the world's most pizza-saturated cities.

Visit the official website or their social media for current locations, hours, and seasonal menu specials.

SoHoOrigin
NYCRegion
SicilianStyle
$$Price range
Common questions

Prince Street Pizza — frequently asked questions

Quick answers to the most common questions about the menu, the Spicy Spring, and visiting.

What is Prince Street Pizza famous for?

Prince Street Pizza is most famous for the Spicy Spring — a square Sicilian-style slice with spicy vodka sauce, pepperoni, and fresh mozzarella on a dough with a distinctively crispy, caramelized bottom and an airy, open crumb. The slice became one of New York City's most-photographed and most-talked-about pizza items, drawing long sidewalk lines and a devoted celebrity following at its SoHo location.

Where is Prince Street Pizza located?

Prince Street Pizza started in SoHo, Manhattan (27 Prince Street, New York, NY) and has expanded to additional NYC locations. Confirm current addresses and hours at princestreetpizza.com or on their Instagram before visiting — hours can vary and lines can be long during peak times.

What is the Spicy Spring slice at Prince Street Pizza?

The Spicy Spring is Prince Street Pizza's signature square Sicilian slice. It's built on their thick, airy dough with a crispy caramelized underside, then topped with a spicy vodka sauce, cupped pepperoni, and fresh mozzarella. The combination of the spicy, creamy sauce with the crispy-bottomed Sicilian base is what sets it apart. It's widely considered one of the best single slices in New York City.

Is Prince Street Pizza Sicilian style?

Yes. Prince Street Pizza specializes in square Sicilian-style pizza, characterized by thick, airy, focaccia-like dough baked in an oiled pan until the bottom is deeply crispy and caramelized. This is distinct from the thin, foldable New York round-slice style. The thick crust provides structural support for rich toppings like the spicy vodka sauce on the Spicy Spring.

Does Prince Street Pizza have a menu online with prices?

Prince Street Pizza does not publish a full priced menu online as of our last review in May 2026. The menu is best viewed in person at the counter or via their official website and Instagram (princestreetpizza.com). Expect to pay a premium over typical NYC slice shop prices, in line with their SoHo location and ingredient quality.

Is Prince Street Pizza worth the wait?

Prince Street Pizza regularly appears on best-of-NYC-pizza lists and the lines — especially for the Spicy Spring — are frequently cited as worth it. The crispy-bottomed, airy Sicilian dough combined with the spicy vodka sauce sets it apart from typical NYC pizza. If you go during off-peak hours (mid-afternoon on a weekday), the wait is typically shorter.

Does Prince Street Pizza do delivery?

Prince Street Pizza is available on delivery apps (availability varies by location and app). Check the Slice, DoorDash, or Uber Eats apps for current delivery coverage and hours. Walk-in and pickup remain the most reliable way to get a fresh slice.

What makes Prince Street Pizza's crust different?

The crust is a square Sicilian-style dough — thick, airy, and made with a long ferment that develops flavor and creates an open crumb structure. The dough is baked in a well-oiled pan at high heat, which produces the signature deeply crispy, caramelized bottom while keeping the interior pillowy and light. This two-texture contrast — crunchy underside, soft crumb — is central to Prince Street's identity.

How does Prince Street Pizza compare to Di Fara or Roberta's?

All three are celebrated NYC pizza institutions but in different styles. Di Fara (Brooklyn) is a thin-crust New York–style and Sicilian spot; Roberta's (Bushwick) is a Neapolitan-leaning wood-fired pie destination; Prince Street is specifically focused on the square Sicilian slice, particularly the spicy vodka sauce build. Prince Street has the most approachable format for a quick slice; Di Fara and Roberta's require more of a sit-down or long-wait commitment.

More restaurant menus on Menupedia

Full menus, signature items, and location guides for restaurants across the U.S. New restaurants added on a rolling basis.

Browse the directory How we work