Menupedia is an independent reference. Not affiliated with any restaurant listed. Menu data reviewed May 2026 — confirm with the official source before ordering.
Menupedia
Mexican · Key West, FL

Old Town Mexican Cafe Menu & Prices 2026: Full List, Tacos & House Favorites

Old Town Mexican Cafe has been a cornerstone of Key West's Duval Street dining scene since 1999, drawing locals and tourists alike with Chef Gail Brockway's vibrant Southwest-meets-Mexican menu. From the $3 basket of chips and salsa to the signature Banana Enchilada dessert, the cafe pairs bold flavors with one of the largest tequila collections in the Florida Keys.

609 Duval St, Key West200+ tequilasDine-in · No delivery
Jump to full menu Cheapest items
Sample · $$

Signature items

Steak Fajitas$28.00
Carne Asada (10 oz)$34.50
Lobster & Shrimp Enchiladas$28.50
Key Lime Pie$10.50
Jump to: Quick answers Full menu Cheapest items Most popular Compare prices About FAQ
Quick answers

What to order — at a glance

Cheapest item
Basket of Chips & Salsa $3.00
Most popular
Steak Fajitas $28.00

A Duval Street staple

Best value dessert
Toasted Coconut Flan $9.00
Splurge item
Carne Asada 12 oz $38.50
Full menu with prices

Old Town Mexican Cafe full menu and current prices

Prices are from the restaurant's official menu (November 2025 PDF). Verify current prices on-site or by calling (305) 296-7500.
Appetizers9 itemsSoups & Salads6 itemsFajitas5 itemsHouse Favorites15 itemsTacos5 itemsEnchiladas4 itemsTostadas5 itemsBurritos5 itemsQuesadillas5 itemsSides5 itemsDesserts6 itemsDrinks8 items
Budget picks

Cheapest items on the Old Town Mexican Cafe menu

  1. 1Basket of Chips and Salsa$3.00
  2. 2Sour Cream (side)$2.50
  3. 3Domestic Beer (Happy Hour)$4.00
  4. 4Spanish Rice / Black Beans / Pinto Beans$4.50
  5. 5Iced Tea$4.50
  6. 6Casamientos$5.00
  7. 7Papas Fritas$5.50
  8. 8Guacamole (side)$6.00
  9. 9Roast Fresh Corn$8.00
  10. 10Toasted Coconut Flan$9.00
Price comparison

Fajita prices by protein

Old Town Mexican Cafe's fajitas come in five protein options. Here's how prices stack up.

Fajita TypePrice
Veggie$20.50
Chicken$24.50
Shrimp$26.50
Steak (8 oz Angus)$28.00
Combo (chicken, shrimp, steak)$29.50
Price comparison

How Old Town Mexican Cafe prices compare to other Mexican restaurants

Like-for-like comparison of common categories at Key West and national Mexican dining options.

CategoryOld Town Mexican CafeRosa MexicanoPappasito's CantinaTaco Bell
Cheapest item$3.00 (chips & salsa)$5.00 (chips & salsa)$3.50 (side)$1.00 (taco)
Fajitas (chicken)$24.50$29.00$25.00n/a
Enchiladas$19.00–$28.50$22.00–$32.00$16.00–$20.00$5.49
Seafood entree$28.50–$34.50$32.00–$44.00$24.00–$38.00n/a
Dessert$8.50–$11.00$9.00–$14.00$7.00–$10.00$2.00
About

About Old Town Mexican Cafe

Old Town Mexican Cafe opened its doors in 1999 on Key West's legendary Duval Street, quickly establishing itself as an anchor of the island's dining scene. Under the culinary direction of Chef Gail Brockway, the kitchen departs from generic Tex-Mex to offer vibrant Southwest-inspired and authentically Mexican dishes — from Santa Fe-style Carne Adobada to house-made Tamales Grande and the crowd-pleasing Mexican Lasagna. The restaurant accommodates a wide range of dietary preferences, with dedicated vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-friendly options throughout the menu.

The bar is equally celebrated, housing over 200 varieties of tequila and mezcal — one of the largest selections in all of the Florida Keys. Daily happy hour from 4–6 PM draws both regulars and visitors with half-price appetizers and discounted cocktails, while Taco Tuesdays offer $4 tacos all day long. The café's front patio on Duval Street provides prime people-watching, blending Key West's free-spirited ambience with the warmth of genuine Mexican hospitality.

Old Town Mexican Cafe has earned a loyal following and multiple local dining awards over its more than two decades in operation. Its dessert menu — particularly the Award-Winning Banana Enchilada with caramel sauce and the Very Traditional Key Lime Pie — draws diners back even after the main course has long been finished. Whether you arrive for a leisurely dinner or a quick lunch, the cafe delivers an experience that reflects Key West's unique character: relaxed, flavorful, and impossible to forget.

1999founded
200+tequila varieties
$$price range

Ready to visit Old Town Mexican Cafe?

Find current hours, confirm today's prices, and explore the full tequila list on the official site.

Visit Old Town Mexican Cafe's website
FAQ

Frequently asked questions

Where is Old Town Mexican Cafe located?

Old Town Mexican Cafe is located at 609 Duval Street in Key West, Florida 33040. It sits in the heart of the historic Old Town district, right on Key West's most famous pedestrian strip.

What are Old Town Mexican Cafe's hours?

The restaurant is open Monday through Thursday from 11:30 AM to 10 PM, and Friday through Sunday from 11 AM to 10 PM. Hours may vary on holidays — call (305) 296-7500 to confirm.

Does Old Town Mexican Cafe have a happy hour?

Yes. Happy hour runs daily from 4–6 PM and includes half-price appetizers plus discounted drinks: margaritas and sangria for $7, house wine and imported beer for $5, domestic beer for $4, and house liquor for $5. Taco Tuesdays offer $4 tacos all day long.

How many tequilas does Old Town Mexican Cafe carry?

The restaurant stocks over 200 varieties of tequila and mezcal, making it one of the largest selections in the Florida Keys. Ask your server for a flight or pairing recommendation.

Does Old Town Mexican Cafe offer vegetarian or vegan options?

Yes. The menu has strong vegetarian and vegan coverage, including Veggie Fajitas ($20.50), Fried Avocado Tacos ($20.50), Black Bean & Avocado Tacos ($22.50), the Garden Burrito ($20.50), Veggieladas ($19.00), Grilled Veggie Plate ($20.50), and a Veggie Tamale Grande ($20.50). Guacamole, avocado salad, casamientos, and papas fritas are also vegan-friendly.

What is the most expensive item on the menu?

The 12 oz Carne Asada — a Black Angus churrasco steak with chimichurri, rice and black beans — tops the food menu at $38.50. Among appetizers, the Tuna Tostada at $20.50 is the priciest starter.

What desserts are famous at Old Town Mexican Cafe?

The restaurant is particularly proud of its Award-Winning Banana Enchilada ($11.00), made with caramel sauce and whipped cream. The Very Traditional Key Lime Pie ($10.50) is a must for first-timers, and the Ghirardelli Chocolate Chile Brownie ($10.50) with coffee ice cream and rum chocolate drizzle is a fan favorite.

Does Old Town Mexican Cafe take reservations?

Reservations are not widely advertised for this casual Key West dining spot. It is best to call ahead at (305) 296-7500, especially during peak tourist season (winter and spring break) when Duval Street is busiest.

Is Old Town Mexican Cafe good for gluten-free diners?

Several items are naturally gluten-friendly, including the Carne Asada, Kabob de Pollo, Lime Cilantro Shrimp, Grilled Veggie Plate, and fresh guacamole. Always inform your server of any dietary restrictions so the kitchen can take appropriate precautions, as some dishes are prepared in a shared kitchen environment.