How much does a pizza slice cost at Nonna's Staten Island?

A regular slice at Nonna's Old Fashioned Pizzeria starts at $4.20. Specialty slices run from $4.80 (White or Pepperoni) to $5.40 (Sicilian, Vodka, Margherita, Grandpa, MOR, and others). The most expensive single slice is the Stuffed Slice at $11.25. Prices are from the online ordering menu at nonnaspizzasi.com.

What is the Nonna's Pie and how much does it cost?

The Nonna's Pie is the house signature 18" pizza priced at $29.99. It's listed among the specialty pies and represents the restaurant's own classic recipe. For the exact build and toppings, call the restaurant at (718) 227-8108 or order online at nonnaspizzasi.com.

Does Nonna's Staten Island offer gluten-free pizza?

Yes. Nonna's offers a Gluten Free Pizza priced at $22.80 and a Cauliflower Crust Pie at $20.40. If you have celiac disease or a severe gluten sensitivity, confirm cross-contact handling directly with the restaurant at (718) 227-8108, as shared kitchen surfaces are common in pizzerias.

What are the hours and locations of Nonna's Pizzeria in Staten Island?

Nonna's Old Fashioned Pizzeria operates daily from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM at two Staten Island locations: 27 Brower Court, Great Kills (10308) at (718) 227-8108, and 311 Page Avenue, Tottenville (10307) at (718) 709-0307. Both locations offer pickup and free delivery. Confirm current hours at nonnaspizzasi.com before visiting.

Does Nonna's deliver, and is delivery free?

Yes. Both Nonna's Staten Island locations offer free delivery with online ordering through nonnaspizzasi.com. You can also place delivery orders through third-party platforms. Minimum order amounts and delivery radius may apply; confirm with the restaurant when ordering.

What pasta dishes does Nonna's Staten Island serve?

Nonna's menu includes 18 pasta dishes: from classics like Spaghetti with Meatballs ($21.60), Lasagna ($19.80), and Baked Ziti ($20.40) to Italian favorites like Pasta Carbonara ($21.60), Pasta Vodka ($19.20), Pasta with Clam Sauce ($21.90), and Pasta with Broccoli Rabe & Sausage ($24.00). The cheapest pasta is Pasta Marinara at $17.35.

What are the cheapest items on the Nonna's menu?

The most affordable items at Nonna's are: Zeppoles ($4.00), Regular Slice ($4.20), Side of Dressing ($4.00), Side of Sauce ($4.50), Rice Ball ($6.00), and Garlic Knots (6) ($7.80). Among drinks, a 20 oz. soda or bottled water runs $3.50. For a full meal on a budget, a regular slice at $4.20 plus a garlic roll or garlic knots is the most economical combination on the menu.

What are the most popular specialty pies at Nonna's?

Nonna's signature specialty pies (all 18") include the Garbage Pie ($42.00) — the most loaded and priciest pie on the menu — plus fan favorites like the Vodka Pie ($37.80), Buffalo Chicken Pie ($37.80), Clam Pie in red or white ($36.00), and the Grandpa Pie ($35.40), a thick Sicilian-style square. The house signature Nonna's Pie is the most affordable specialty at $29.99.

Does Nonna's Staten Island have vegetarian options?

Yes. Nonna's has a wide range of vegetarian choices. On the pizza side: the Vegetarian Pie ($39.59), Margherita Pie ($30.50), White Pie ($31.20), Vodka Pie ($37.80) and most plain and cheese-only pies are meatless. Pasta options include Baked Ziti ($20.40), Pasta Primavera ($20.40), Pasta Vodka ($19.20), and Pasta Alfredo ($19.20). Entrees include three eggplant preparations ($22.20-$23.70). Heros include the Eggplant Parmigiana Hero ($17.10), Potato & Egg, and Pepper & Egg.

Nonna's Staten Island Menu & Prices 2026

Name: Nonna's Old Fashioned Pizzeria
Price range: $$

The full priced menu

Nonna's Old Fashioned Pizzeria complete menu with 2026 prices

All categories below. Tags flag vegetarian and gluten-free items. Prices are from the nonnaspizzasi.com online ordering system.

About these prices. Prices shown are from the Nonna's online ordering menu at nonnaspizzasi.com, reviewed June 2026. Prices shown are base starting prices; add-ons, substitutions and in-store pricing may differ. Confirm current pricing when ordering.

Appetizers 23 items

Garlic BreadClassic garlic bread, baked fresh.

$10.20

Garlic Bread with CheeseGarlic bread topped with melted cheese.

$11.95

Mozzarella Sticks (6)Six golden-fried mozzarella sticks.

$16.50

Mozzarella en CarozzaItalian-style fried mozzarella in a carriage of bread.

$16.20

Mac & Cheese Bites (12)Twelve crispy fried mac and cheese bites.

$16.20

Fried ZucchiniVegetarianLightly battered and fried zucchini strips.

$16.80

Baked Clams (8)Eight baked clams with garlic and herbs.

$18.00

Hot AntipastoA warm platter of assorted Italian antipasto.

$23.40

Shrimp Cocktail (6)Six chilled shrimp served with cocktail sauce.

$19.20

Fried Shrimp (6)Six crispy fried shrimp.

$19.20

Fried CalamariTender calamari rings lightly battered and fried.

$19.20

Clams on Half Shell (12)One dozen raw clams on the half shell.

$21.60

Mussels MarinaraSteamed mussels in a house marinara sauce.

$18.60

Sauteed SpinachVegetarianFresh spinach sauteed with garlic and olive oil.

$15.60

Sauteed BroccoliVegetarianBroccoli sauteed with garlic and olive oil.

$15.60

Sauteed Broccoli RabeVegetarianBroccoli rabe sauteed in garlic and olive oil.

$20.40

Rice BallClassic Italian-American arancini rice ball.

$6.00

Rice Ball ParmigianaRice ball topped with marinara and melted cheese.

$12.00

Eggplant Rolatini (2)VegetarianTwo rolled eggplant filled with ricotta and baked.

$16.20

Buffalo Wings (10)Ten chicken wings tossed in Buffalo sauce.

$18.60

Chicken Fingers (6)Six crispy breaded chicken fingers.

$16.20

French FriesVegetarianClassic golden French fries.

$12.50

Onion RingsVegetarianCrispy breaded onion rings.

$12.50

Handmade Rolls & Calzones 9 items

Roll (Broccoli, Chicken, Eggplant, Pepperoni, Sausage, or Spinach)Freshly baked handmade roll with your choice of filling.

$12.00

Stromboli (Ham, Pepperoni, Salami & Mozzarella)Classic stromboli stuffed with ham, pepperoni, salami and mozzarella.

$13.80

Buffalo Chicken RollHandmade roll stuffed with spicy Buffalo chicken.

$13.80

Garlic Knots (6)VegetarianSix soft garlic knots, a Staten Island staple.

$7.80

ZeppolesVegetarianLight Italian fried dough dusted with powdered sugar.

$4.00

Calzone SmallVegetarianSmall calzone with ricotta and mozzarella.

$10.00

Calzone Small with ToppingSmall calzone with ricotta, mozzarella and one topping of your choice.

$11.00

Large Family Size CalzoneVegetarianOversized family calzone with ricotta and mozzarella.

$17.50

Large Family Calzone with ToppingFamily calzone with ricotta, mozzarella and one topping.

$19.50

Specialty Pies (18") 23 items

Clam Pie (Red or White)18" pie loaded with clams, either red (marinara) or white (garlic and olive oil).

$36.00

Chicken Marsala Pie18" pie with chicken marsala, mushrooms and mozzarella.

$37.80

Chicken Parmigiana Pie18" pie with breaded chicken cutlet, marinara and mozzarella.

$37.80

Fresca PieVegetarian18" pie with fresh tomatoes, basil and mozzarella.

$35.40

La Caprese PieVegetarian18" pie inspired by caprese salad with tomato, fresh mozzarella and basil.

$34.20

White PieVegetarian18" white pizza with ricotta, mozzarella and garlic, no tomato sauce.

$31.20

Buffalo Chicken Pie18" pie with spicy Buffalo chicken and mozzarella.

$37.80

Chicken Caesar Salad Pie18" pie topped with grilled chicken and Caesar salad.

$34.80

Garbage Pie18" loaded specialty pie piled high with multiple toppings.

$42.00

Deep Dish Pepperoni Pie18" deep-dish style pie loaded with pepperoni.

$35.40

Vodka PieVegetarian18" pie with creamy vodka sauce and mozzarella.

$37.80

Chicken Francese Pie18" pie with chicken francese (egg-battered chicken in lemon-butter sauce).

$36.00

Margherita PieVegetarian18" Margherita with tomato, fresh mozzarella and basil.

$30.50

Grandpa Pie18" Sicilian-style grandpa pie — thick, square, crispy-edged.

$35.40

Vegetarian PieVegetarian18" pie loaded with mixed vegetables.

$39.59

Spinach & Artichoke PieVegetarian18" pie with spinach, artichoke hearts and mozzarella.

$37.19

Alfredo Bacon Pie18" pie with Alfredo sauce, crispy bacon and mozzarella.

$37.80

Garlic Marinara PieVegetarian18" pie with garlic and marinara, light on cheese.

$31.19

Pan PieVegetarian18" pan-style pizza with thick dough.

$32.39

M.O.R Pie18" signature M.O.R (mozzarella, olive oil, roasted garlic) pie.

$37.80

Chicken Bruschetta Pie18" pie with grilled chicken and fresh bruschetta topping.

$37.80

Nonna's PieVegetarian18" signature Nonna's pie — the house classic.

$29.99

Philly Cheesesteak Pie18" pie with shaved steak, peppers, onions and cheese.

$38.39

Old Fashioned Gourmet Pizza 4 items

18" Large PieVegetarianClassic 18" old-fashioned pizza with tomato sauce and mozzarella.

$25.20

Sicilian PieVegetarianThick-square Sicilian pizza with tomato sauce and mozzarella.

$32.40

Cauliflower Crust PieVegetarianGluten-freeLower-carb pizza on a cauliflower crust.

$20.40

Gluten Free PizzaGluten-freeVegetarianPersonal-size pizza on a gluten-free crust. Confirm cross-contact handling with the restaurant.

$22.80

Stuffed Pizza 4 items

Stuffed Broccoli & SpinachVegetarianThick double-crusted stuffed pizza loaded with broccoli and spinach.

$40.20

Stuffed Fried EggplantVegetarianStuffed pizza filled with fried eggplant and ricotta.

$40.20

Stuffed Sausage & PeppersStuffed pizza loaded with Italian sausage and peppers.

$38.40

Roman PizzaRoman-style stuffed pizza with a crispy exterior.

$38.40

Pizza Slices 15 items

Regular SliceVegetarianClassic tomato sauce and mozzarella slice.

$4.20

Sicilian SliceVegetarianThick-square Sicilian slice.

$5.40

Upside Down SliceVegetarianSauce-on-top Sicilian-style slice.

$5.40

Chipotle SliceSlice with chipotle sauce and toppings.

$5.40

White SliceVegetarianWhite pizza slice with ricotta, mozzarella and garlic.

$4.80

Vodka SliceVegetarianSlice with creamy vodka sauce.

$5.40

Artichoke Spinach SliceVegetarianSlice topped with artichoke hearts and spinach.

$5.40

Burrata SliceVegetarianSlice finished with creamy burrata.

$6.00

Pepperoni SliceClassic slice loaded with pepperoni.

$4.80

MOR SliceMozzarella, olive oil and roasted garlic slice.

$5.40

Deep Dish Pan Roni SliceDeep-dish pan-style pepperoni slice.

$5.40

Nonna SliceVegetarianHouse signature Nonna's style slice.

$5.40

Grandpa SliceVegetarianGrandpa-style thick-crust Sicilian slice.

$5.40

Margherita SliceVegetarianFresh tomato, mozzarella and basil slice.

$5.40

Stuffed SliceA slice of double-crusted stuffed pizza.

$11.25

Soups 5 items

Tortellini in BrodoCheese tortellini in a clear chicken broth.

$8.95

Tortellini in Brodo with SpinachCheese tortellini and spinach in chicken broth.

$10.15

Pasta FagioliVegetarianHearty Italian pasta and white bean soup.

$7.80

Chicken Noodle SoupClassic chicken noodle soup.

$7.80

Lentil SoupVegetarianHearty lentil soup.

$7.80

Pasta 18 items

Pasta with Clam Sauce (Red or White)Your choice of pasta with either red or white clam sauce.

$21.90

Pasta PomodoroVegetarianPasta with fresh tomato pomodoro sauce.

$21.00

Pasta PuttanescaPasta with olives, capers, anchovies and tomato sauce.

$20.40

Baked ZitiVegetarianZiti baked with marinara, ricotta and mozzarella.

$20.40

ManicottiVegetarianPasta tubes stuffed with ricotta and baked in marinara.

$18.50

Stuffed ShellsVegetarianLarge pasta shells stuffed with ricotta in marinara sauce.

$18.50

Pasta BolognesePasta with a hearty slow-cooked meat and tomato Bolognese.

$18.00

Pasta Garlic & OilVegetarianPasta tossed with olive oil, garlic and herbs.

$16.20

Pasta AlfredoVegetarianPasta in a rich cream and Parmesan Alfredo sauce.

$19.20

Pasta with Broccoli Garlic & OilVegetarianPasta with broccoli, garlic and olive oil.

$19.20

Pasta CarbonaraPasta in a classic egg and Pecorino sauce with pancetta.

$21.60

Pasta PrimaveraVegetarianPasta with a medley of fresh vegetables.

$20.40

Pasta VodkaVegetarianPasta in a creamy vodka tomato sauce.

$19.20

LasagnaLayered pasta with beef, ricotta, mozzarella and marinara.

$19.80

RavioliVegetarianRicotta-filled ravioli with marinara or butter sauce.

$18.60

Spaghetti with MeatballsSpaghetti topped with house marinara and two large meatballs.

$21.60

Pasta with Broccoli Rabe & SausagePasta with sauteed broccoli rabe and Italian sausage.

$24.00

Pasta MarinaraVegetarianPasta with house marinara sauce.

$17.35

Entrees 24 items

Eggplant ParmigianaVegetarianBreaded eggplant layered with marinara and mozzarella, baked.

$22.20

Eggplant FlorentineVegetarianEggplant with spinach and ricotta filling.

$23.70

Eggplant RollatiniVegetarianThin eggplant rolled around a ricotta filling and baked.

$23.70

Veal FranceseTender veal scallopini in a lemon-butter egg-battered francese sauce.

$28.20

Veal ParmigianaBreaded veal cutlet with marinara and melted mozzarella.

$26.40

Chicken ParmigianaBreaded chicken cutlet with marinara sauce and mozzarella.

$24.60

Veal MarsalaTender veal in a rich Marsala wine and mushroom sauce.

$28.20

Chicken MarsalaChicken in a Marsala wine and mushroom sauce.

$24.90

Chicken FranceseEgg-battered chicken cutlet in a lemon-butter sauce.

$24.30

Chicken RollatiniThin chicken breast rolled with a filling and baked.

$26.70

Shrimp ParmigianaBreaded shrimp with marinara and melted mozzarella.

$25.80

Shrimp FranceseShrimp in a lemon-butter egg-battered sauce.

$26.40

Shrimp OreganatoShrimp baked with seasoned breadcrumbs and oregano.

$26.40

Shrimp ScampiShrimp sauteed in garlic, white wine and butter.

$26.40

Shrimp MarinaraShrimp in a hearty marinara sauce.

$25.50

Calamari & Clams MarinaraCalamari and clams in marinara sauce.

$26.90

Clams & Shrimp MarinaraClams and shrimp in a house marinara sauce.

$29.30

Shrimp & CalamariShrimp and calamari prepared together in a savory sauce.

$30.50

Zuppa di MusselsMussels in a flavorful zuppa broth with garlic and wine.

$25.45

Zuppa di PesceA rich seafood stew with mixed fish in a white wine and tomato broth.

$31.75

Calamari MarinaraCalamari in marinara sauce.

$25.80

Scungili MarinaraScungili (conch) in a classic marinara sauce.

$25.80

Grilled Chicken with Broccoli RabeGrilled chicken breast served with sauteed broccoli rabe.

$25.50

Grilled Chicken with Grilled VegetablesGrilled chicken breast with a side of grilled seasonal vegetables.

$21.60

Heros 19 items

Chicken Marsala HeroChicken Marsala in a hero roll.

$19.20

Chicken Parmigiana HeroBreaded chicken cutlet with marinara and mozzarella on a hero roll.

$18.30

Grilled Chicken with Mozzarella HeroGrilled chicken with fresh mozzarella on a hero roll.

$17.70

Eggplant Parmigiana HeroVegetarianEggplant parmigiana on a hero roll.

$17.10

Meatball Parmigiana HeroMeatballs with marinara and mozzarella on a hero roll.

$17.10

Sausage Parmigiana HeroItalian sausage with marinara and mozzarella on a hero roll.

$17.10

Veal Parmigiana HeroVeal parmigiana on a hero roll.

$20.10

Shrimp Parmigiana HeroShrimp parmigiana on a hero roll.

$18.90

Potato & Egg HeroVegetarianClassic potato and egg Italian hero.

$15.30

Pepper & Egg HeroVegetarianClassic pepper and egg Italian hero.

$15.30

Broccoli Rabe & Sausage HeroSauteed broccoli rabe and Italian sausage on a hero roll.

$18.90

Broccoli Rabe & Chicken Cutlet HeroBroccoli rabe and breaded chicken cutlet hero.

$16.25

Chicken Francese HeroChicken francese in a hero roll.

$18.90

Chicken Cacciatore HeroBraised chicken cacciatore on a hero roll.

$18.30

Sausage, Pepper & Onion HeroItalian sausage with sauteed peppers and onions on a hero roll.

$17.70

Veal Marsala HeroVeal Marsala on a hero roll.

$18.25

Veal Francese HeroVeal Francese in a hero roll.

$18.00

Philly Cheesesteak HeroShaved steak with melted cheese on a hero roll.

$17.75

Philly Cheesesteak with Peppers, Onions & Mushrooms HeroPhilly cheesesteak loaded with peppers, onions and mushrooms.

$17.75

Salads 9 items

Garden SaladVegetarianFresh mixed greens with vegetables.

$15.30

Garden Salad with ChickenGarden salad topped with grilled chicken.

$17.70

Garden Salad with Grilled ShrimpGarden salad topped with grilled shrimp.

$20.70

Chef SaladHearty chef salad with mixed greens, meats and cheeses.

$22.70

Caesar SaladVegetarianRomaine lettuce with Caesar dressing and croutons.

$14.25

Caesar Salad with ChickenCaesar salad topped with grilled chicken.

$18.10

Tuna SaladHouse tuna salad over greens.

$21.00

Cold AntipastoChilled platter of assorted Italian cured meats, cheeses and vegetables.

$21.00

Caprese SaladVegetarianFresh tomato, fresh mozzarella and basil with olive oil.

$19.80

Wraps 11 items

Chicken Caesar WrapGrilled chicken with Caesar dressing and romaine in a wrap.

$14.40

American WrapClassic American-style wrap with assorted fillings.

$15.00

Cheeseburger WrapAll the flavors of a cheeseburger in a wrap.

$16.20

Italian WrapItalian meats and cheese in a wrap.

$15.60

Grilled Chicken, French Mozzarella & Roasted Peppers WrapGrilled chicken with fresh mozzarella and roasted peppers.

$15.60

Buffalo Chicken WrapSpicy Buffalo chicken wrap.

$15.00

Eggplant WrapVegetarianEggplant parmigiana in a wrap.

$15.60

Grilled Vegetables WrapVegetarianGrilled seasonal vegetables in a wrap.

$15.60

Chicken Broccoli Rabe WrapChicken cutlet with broccoli rabe in a wrap.

$16.50

Honeymoon WrapHouse signature Honeymoon wrap.

$15.60

Vodka WrapVegetarianWrap with a creamy vodka sauce.

$15.60

Burgers 6 items

BurgerClassic beef burger on a bun.

$15.00

CheeseburgerBurger topped with melted American cheese.

$16.20

Bacon CheeseburgerCheeseburger with crispy bacon.

$16.20

Bacon Cheeseburger Special with FriesBacon cheeseburger served with a side of fries.

$20.40

Pizza BurgerBurger topped with marinara and mozzarella, pizza-style.

$17.40

Cheeseburger Special with FriesCheeseburger served with a side of fries.

$18.60

Sides 6 items

Side of SauceVegetarianSide of house marinara sauce.

$4.50

Side of DressingVegetarianSide of salad dressing.

$4.00

Side of Grated CheeseVegetarianSide of grated Parmesan/Pecorino cheese.

$6.50

Side of Vodka SauceVegetarianSide of house vodka cream sauce.

$6.50

Side of Meatballs (2)Two house-made beef meatballs in marinara.

$11.75

Side of SausageItalian sausage as a side.

$11.75

Beverages 7 items

2-Liter Coke2-liter bottle of Coca-Cola.

$4.50

2-Liter Diet Coke2-liter bottle of Diet Coca-Cola.

$4.50

2-Liter Sprite2-liter bottle of Sprite.

$4.50

20 oz. Coke20 oz. bottle of Coca-Cola.

$3.50

20 oz. Diet Coke20 oz. bottle of Diet Coca-Cola.

$3.50

20 oz. Sprite20 oz. bottle of Sprite.

$3.50

Bottled WaterBottled water.

$3.50

Nonna's Staten Island Menu & Prices 2026: Pizza, Pasta & Full Menu

Nonna's menu questions answered at a glance

The 10 cheapest items at Nonna's Staten Island

Nonna's signature and specialty pies to know

Nonna's Pie (18")

Garbage Pie (18")

Grandpa Pie (18")

Clam Pie Red or White (18")

Chicken Parmigiana Hero

Garlic Knots (6)

Most-ordered items at Nonna's

Jump to a menu category

Nonna's Old Fashioned Pizzeria complete menu with 2026 prices

Appetizers 23 items

Handmade Rolls & Calzones 9 items

Specialty Pies (18") 23 items

Old Fashioned Gourmet Pizza 4 items

Stuffed Pizza 4 items

Pizza Slices 15 items

Soups 5 items

Pasta 18 items

Entrees 24 items

Heros 19 items

Salads 9 items

Wraps 11 items

Burgers 6 items

Sides 6 items

Beverages 7 items

Vegetarian and gluten-free options at Nonna's

How to get the most out of Nonna's menu

Order the Nonna's Pie first

Online ordering saves a trip

Mix slices for smaller groups

The Zuppa di Pesce is the premium entree

Garlic knots and zeppoles under $8

Call ahead for GF orders

Nonna's Old Fashioned Pizzeria Staten Island locations

Staten Island's old-fashioned neighborhood pizzeria

Nonna's Staten Island menu — frequently asked questions

More restaurant menus on Menupedia