Pizza by the Slice 2 items
New York Cheese SliceVegetarianClassic hand-tossed thin-crust New York-style cheese pizza by the slice.
$5.99
Old World Cheese SliceVegetarianOld-world style cheese pizza by the slice.
$6.99
Full GoodFella's Pizzeria & Grill menu prices for 2026 -- every category, every item, with prices as published on the restaurant's own ordering site. Located at 2237 Powell St in San Francisco's North Beach, GoodFellas serves NY-style and Old World pizza by the slice (from $5.99) or whole (from $18.99), halal specialty pies, pasta, calzones, sandwiches, burgers, kabobs and more. Below: the at-a-glance price highlights, the full priced menu, house combo deals, and answers to the most common questions.
Signature items
The four most-searched facts about GoodFella's Pizzeria & Grill -- answered at a glance.
New York-style thin-crust cheese slice. Old World Cheese Slice is $6.99.
The restaurant's namesake signature specialty pie -- a North Beach favorite.
The most affordable complete meal deal on the House Specials board.
Generously stuffed house calzone, oven-baked -- one of the menu's standout items.
The House Specials board bundles pizza, sides and drinks for the best per-dollar value on the menu. Four deals currently available as published on goodfellaspizzasf.com.
Best per-dollar entry deal on the menu. Available during regular store hours.
Also available with 2 cans of soda at the same $30.99 price.
Full meal bundle. Salad choices include Caesar, Greek, GoodFellas or House.
Same price as the salad bundle -- wings or salad, your choice.
Ranked by published price. A cheese slice at $5.99 is the most affordable single item on the menu. Every item below is under $14.
GoodFella's Pizzeria offers 14+ specialty pizza builds beyond the base cheese pies. Highlights below. Call (415) 398-1000 or visit goodfellaspizzasf.com for current specialty prices.
The restaurant's namesake specialty -- a North Beach fan favorite. Ask at the counter for the current build and pricing.
Hummus base instead of tomato sauce, topped with Mediterranean ingredients. One of the most distinctive pies on the SF pizza scene.
Garlic white sauce base with halal chicken. GoodFellas is one of the few SF pizzerias with confirmed halal meat toppings.
Tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella and basil on a hand-tossed thin crust. The benchmark vegetarian pizza on the menu.
A distinct old-world style crust and cheese build -- priced at $19.90 whole or $6.99 per slice, slightly above the NY Cheese base.
The house calzone at $20.99 -- generously stuffed and oven-baked. Pairs with marinara dipping sauce. A menu standout beyond the pizza lineup.
All menu categories at GoodFella's Pizzeria & Grill with item counts.
GoodFella's Pizzeria & Grill sits at 2237 Powell St in San Francisco's North Beach / Telegraph Hill neighborhood -- one of the city's most storied dining districts. The restaurant built its reputation on hand-tossed New York-style thin-crust pizza alongside an unusual offering for the Bay Area: halal-certified meat toppings across a wide specialty pizza lineup.
Beyond pizza, GoodFellas runs a full grill menu -- kabobs served with rice, hummus and bread; Philly cheesesteaks on Dutch crunch rolls; all-beef grilled hot dogs; full pasta dishes; calzones and strombolis. The restaurant has been a Slice online-ordering partner for over 14 years, with 400+ Yelp reviews and a 4.0-star average as of 2026.
Online ordering: goodfellaspizzasf.com | Phone: (415) 398-1000
GoodFellas offers a solid vegetarian pizza selection and advertises halal meats -- one of the distinguishing features for a San Francisco pizzeria. The pasta menu is entirely vegetarian. For gluten-free or allergen questions, call (415) 398-1000 directly.
Cross-contact possible in a shared kitchen. Always confirm with the restaurant for serious dietary needs.
Address: 2237 Powell St, San Francisco, CA 94133 (North Beach / Telegraph Hill)
Phone: (415) 398-1000
Online ordering: goodfellaspizzasf.com
GoodFellas is located in San Francisco's North Beach neighborhood, steps from Washington Square Park and accessible by Muni. The restaurant is close to the Powell-Mason cable car line.
If you are choosing between GoodFella's and another pizza spot -- or looking for the next pizza menu to explore -- these are the closest comparisons on Menupedia.
Quick answers to the most common questions about GoodFella's Pizzeria: location, hours, prices, halal menu and online ordering.
GoodFella's Pizzeria & Grill is located at 2237 Powell St, San Francisco, CA 94133, in the North Beach / Telegraph Hill neighborhood. Phone: (415) 398-1000. The restaurant is accessible via BART and Muni, with the Powell Street BART/Muni station nearby.
GoodFella's Pizzeria is open Monday through Thursday 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM, Friday and Saturday 11:00 AM to 11:00 PM, and Sunday 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM. Hours may vary on holidays -- confirm by calling (415) 398-1000 before visiting.
Whole pizza prices at GoodFella's Pizzeria start at $18.99 for a New York Cheese Pizza and $19.90 for an Old World Cheese Pizza. Specialty pizzas (Smokin' GoodFellas, BBQ Chicken, Chicken Garlic Blanco, etc.) are priced separately -- check the online ordering page on goodfellaspizzasf.com or call the restaurant for current specialty pizza pricing. Pizza by the slice starts at $5.99 for a New York cheese slice.
Yes. GoodFella's Pizzeria sells pizza by the slice. A New York Cheese Slice is $5.99 and an Old World Cheese Slice is $6.99. Slices are available during regular business hours while supplies last. The best House Special deal is a Slice with Two Toppings & Soda for $9.99.
Yes. GoodFella's Pizzeria & Grill in San Francisco offers halal specialty pizzas and halal meat options. The restaurant is listed as a halal establishment on Yelp and advertises halal meats including chicken and beef. Confirm specific item halal status by calling the restaurant at (415) 398-1000.
Yes. GoodFella's Pizzeria has several vegetarian options: the Classic Margherita Pizza, Vegetarian Pizza, Pesto Greek Pizza, Mediterranean Hummus Pizza, Four Cheese Pizza, and cheese slices. Vegetarian sides include Mozzarella Sticks ($11.99), Jalapeno Poppers ($11.99), Garlic Bread ($8.99), Mac & Cheese ($13.99), French Fries ($6.99), and all pasta dishes. Desserts (cheesecake, baklava, cookie) are also vegetarian.
Yes. GoodFella's Pizzeria & Grill offers online ordering through their own website at goodfellaspizzasf.com, powered by Slice. The restaurant has been a Slice partner for over 14 years (as of 2026). Online ordering supports delivery and pickup. You can also call (415) 398-1000 to order directly.
The best value House Specials at GoodFella's Pizzeria are: a Slice with Two Toppings & Soda for $9.99 (cheapest combo), a Medium Pizza with 2 Toppings & 2-Liter Soda for $30.99, and a Medium Pizza with 2 Toppings, Garlic Bread, 2L Soda & either a Salad or 6 Wings for $54.99. The pizza + wings + bread + drink deal is the most complete value package at that price point.
GoodFella's Pizzeria & Grill stands out in San Francisco for several reasons: it offers halal-certified meats alongside New York-style and Old World-style pies, making it one of the few SF pizzerias serving a halal menu. The restaurant also offers a wider-than-average menu -- beyond pizza, it serves kabobs with rice and hummus, Philly cheesesteaks on Dutch crunch rolls, grilled all-beef hot dogs and full pasta dishes. It has been a North Beach community fixture and a Slice partner for 14+ years.
Full menus, prices, combos and signature items for U.S. restaurants -- fast food, pizza, coffee, seafood, steakhouses and more. New restaurants added on a rolling basis.
Browse the directory How we work