Menupedia is an independent reference. Not affiliated with any restaurant listed. Menu data reviewed May 2026 — confirm with the official source before ordering.
Menupedia
Pizza · Subs · Casual

Pizza Shoppe Mancelona Menu 2026: Pizzas, Subs & More

The Pizza Shoppe in Mancelona, Michigan serves up handcrafted specialty pizzas available in 10", 12", 14", and 16" sizes, alongside fresh-made subs, salads, wings, and grilled items. A true neighborhood spot in the heart of northern Michigan's Antrim County, the restaurant offers dine-in, carryout, and bulk party orders for the whole community.

4 pizza sizesSpecialty piesDine-in & carryout
Jump to full menu Cheapest items
Sample · $

Signature items

Pizza Shoppe Special
Mighty Meat
Party Pizzas (4×16")$58
Chicken Wings
Jump to: Quick answers Full menu Party specials Most popular Compare prices About FAQ
Quick answers

What to order — at a glance

Best value deal
4 Party Pizzas (16") $58

Four 16" pizzas with cheese and 12 total toppings

Most popular pizza
Pizza Shoppe Special

Cheese, pepperoni, ham, mushroom, onion, green pepper

Meat lovers pick
Mighty Meat

Cheese, pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon

Vegetarian option
Veggie Pizza

Cheese, mushroom, green pepper, onion, green olives, black olives

Combo meals

The Pizza Shoppe combo and meal deals

2-Party Pizza Special$29

  • Two 16" pizzas with cheese
  • 6 total topping selections

Great for families or small gatherings

4-Party Pizza Special$58

  • Four 16" pizzas with cheese
  • 12 total topping selections

Best value — feeds a crowd

Full menu with prices

The Pizza Shoppe full menu and current prices

Individual item prices are not published online. Call (231) 587-5162 or visit in person for current pricing. Party pizza specials are listed where confirmed.
Specialty Pizzas (10", 12", 14", 16")10 itemsParty Pizza Specials2 itemsSalads4 itemsAppetizers & Sides8 itemsFrom the Grill7 itemsSubs (6" & 12")7 itemsBeverages2 items
Budget picks

Cheapest items on the The Pizza Shoppe menu

  1. 1CoffeeBeverage
  2. 2French FriesSide
  3. 3Bread Sticks (4 pc)
  4. 4Grilled Cheese
  5. 5Dinner Salad
  6. 6Mozzarella Sticks
  7. 7Onion Rings
  8. 8BLT Sub (6")
Pizza sizes

Available pizza sizes

All specialty and build-your-own pizzas are available in four sizes. Contact the restaurant for individual pricing.

SizeDiameterBest for
Small10"1–2 people
Medium12"2–3 people
Large14"3–4 people
Party16"4–5 people
Price comparison

How Pizza Shoppe Mancelona compares to pizza chains

Community pizza shop versus national chains — comparing what each offers.

CategoryPizza Shoppe MancelonaPizza HutDomino's
Size options10", 12", 14", 16"Small–XLSmall–XL
Party specials4×16" for $58LimitedVaries
Subs availableYes (6" & 12")NoNo
Wings availableYes (10 pc)YesYes
Local ownershipYesNoNo
About

About The Pizza Shoppe

The Pizza Shoppe in Mancelona, Michigan is a locally owned neighborhood restaurant serving the Antrim County community. Situated in the small northern Michigan town of Mancelona — best known for its rural charm and proximity to lakes and forests — the pizzeria has carved out a loyal following by offering honest, generously topped pizzas at community-friendly prices.

The menu reflects the tastes of a working-class northern Michigan community: thick, satisfying specialty pizzas with names like the Mighty Meat and the Big 10, alongside hearty subs, grilled baskets, and classic American sides. The kitchen prides itself on flexibility — every pizza can be built to order, and the bulk party specials make the shop a go-to for local sports teams, school events, and family gatherings.

With four pizza sizes (10", 12", 14", and 16") and party deals starting at two large pizzas for $29, The Pizza Shoppe has made itself the default answer for feeding a crowd in Mancelona. The restaurant is reachable at (231) 587-5162 for carryout orders and current pricing.

4pizza sizes
$29party special from
$price range

Ready to order from Pizza Shoppe Mancelona?

Call (231) 587-5162 to place a carryout order, ask about daily specials, or get current pricing on individual items.

Visit Pizza Shoppe Mancelona
FAQ

Frequently asked questions

What pizza sizes does Pizza Shoppe Mancelona offer?

The Pizza Shoppe offers pizzas in four sizes: 10" (small), 12" (medium), 14" (large), and 16" (party size). All specialty pizzas and the Build Your Own option are available in all four sizes.

What are the party pizza specials at Pizza Shoppe Mancelona?

The Pizza Shoppe offers two party deals: two 16" pizzas with cheese and 6 total topping selections for $29, or four 16" pizzas with cheese and 12 total topping selections for $58. These represent the best per-slice value on the menu.

Does Pizza Shoppe Mancelona deliver?

Delivery availability is not confirmed on the restaurant's website. Call (231) 587-5162 to ask about current delivery options or to place a carryout order.

What is the most popular pizza at Pizza Shoppe Mancelona?

The Pizza Shoppe Special — loaded with cheese, pepperoni, ham, mushroom, onion, and green pepper — is the restaurant's signature pizza and among the most ordered. The Mighty Meat (pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon) is also very popular with meat lovers.

Are there vegetarian options at Pizza Shoppe Mancelona?

Yes — the Veggie Pizza (cheese, mushroom, green pepper, onion, green olives, black olives), French fries, mozzarella sticks, bread sticks, the Veggie Sub, and the Grilled Cheese are all vegetarian-friendly options.

Does Pizza Shoppe Mancelona have salads?

Yes — the menu includes an Italian Salad, Dinner Salad, Antipasto Salad, and Chicken Salad, each available with house dressing options including Buttermilk Ranch, French, and House Italian.

Can I build my own pizza at Pizza Shoppe Mancelona?

Yes — in addition to the specialty pizzas, the restaurant offers a Build Your Own option where you start with cheese and add any combination of toppings. The Big 10 pizza also lets you choose any 10 toppings of your preference.

What are the sub options at Pizza Shoppe Mancelona?

Subs are available in 6" and 12" sizes and include the Super Sub, BLT, Meatball, Pizza Sub, Veggie Sub, Club Sub, and Calzone. Hot subs like the Meatball and Pizza Sub are particularly popular in the colder northern Michigan months.

Where is Pizza Shoppe Mancelona located?

The Pizza Shoppe is located in Mancelona, Michigan — a small town in Antrim County in northern Michigan's lower peninsula, near Bellaire and Elk Rapids. Call (231) 587-5162 for the exact address and current hours.