Menupedia is an independent reference. Not affiliated with any restaurant listed. Menu data reviewed May 2026 — confirm with the official source before ordering.
Menupedia
American · Tavern

Jack's Tavern Menu Prices 2026: Full List, Burgers, Steaks & More

Jack's Tavern in Millersville, Pennsylvania is a family-owned American tavern celebrated for its hand-ground Black Angus burgers, signature Baltimore-style crabcakes, and slow-roasted pulled pork and brisket. The kitchen grinds its own burger beef on-site from cuts other restaurants use for steaks — and every fried item is cooked in 100% peanut oil.

Millersville, PABlack Angus burgersBaltimore crabcakes100% peanut oil
Jump to full menu Cheapest items
Sample · $$

Signature items

Jack Burger 1/2 Lb.$10.95
Tips Sandwich a'la Jack$16.95
Crabcakes (dinner)$21.95
Filet Mignon$27.95
Jump to: Quick answers Full menu Cheapest items Most popular Compare prices About FAQ
Quick answers

What to order — at a glance

Cheapest item
Regular Hot Dog $2.95
Most popular
Jack Burger 1/2 Lb. $10.95

Hand-ground Black Angus beef, cooked to order

Signature sandwich
Tips Sandwich a'la Jack (Filet Mignon) $16.95
Best seafood item
Crabcakes Dinner $21.95
Full menu with prices

Jack's Tavern full menu and current prices

Prices are from the restaurant's published menu (Nov 2023). Current prices may vary — confirm with your location at (717) 872-8300.
Appetizers22 itemsSoups7 itemsSalads11 itemsSandwiches22 itemsBurgers10 itemsPasta5 itemsDinners6 itemsFrom the Broiler7 itemsFrom the Sea8 itemsOdds & Ends (Sides & Extras)9 items
Budget picks

Cheapest items on the Jack's Tavern menu

  1. 1Regular Hot Dog$2.95
  2. 2Jack's Hot Dog$4.95
  3. 3Chili (cup)$4.95
  4. 4Soup Du Jack (cup)$4.95
  5. 55 Cheese Mac n Cheese$4.95
  6. 6Tossed Salad$5.95
  7. 7Beef Stew (cup)$5.95
  8. 8American Fries$5.95
  9. 9Pierogies (5 pcs)$5.95
  10. 10Grilled Cheese$4.95
Size & price

Spaghetti sizes and burger options: size vs. price

Jack's Tavern lets you size up on spaghetti and offers both quarter- and half-pound burger options.

ItemSizePrice
Spaghetti1/4 lb.$7.95
Spaghetti1/2 lb.$11.95
Spaghetti1 lb.$16.95
Patty Melt1/4 lb.$8.95
Jack Burger1/2 lb.$10.95
Jack the Giant Killer Burger1 lb.$22.95
Jack Sized Sirloin8 oz.$19.95
Jack Sized Sirloin16 oz.$24.95
Filet Mignon10 oz.$27.95
Price comparison

How Jack's Tavern prices compare to similar American taverns

Like-for-like comparison of common categories at bar-and-grill style American restaurants.

CategoryJack's TavernApplebee'sAle House
Basic burger$10.95~$12.00~$13.00
Signature/loaded burger$13.95–$15.95~$14.00~$15.00
Chicken sandwich$10.95–$13.95~$12.00~$13.00
Nachos appetizer$9.95–$13.95~$13.00~$14.00
Steak dinner (premium cut)$24.95–$27.95~$22.00~$26.00
About

About Jack's Tavern

Jack's Tavern — officially Jack's Family Tavern & Restaurant — has been a fixture on South Prince Street in Millersville, Pennsylvania for decades, building a loyal following with generosity, personality, and an unwavering commitment to cooking from scratch. The restaurant grinds its own Black Angus beef on-site each day from cuts other steakhouses reserve for the broiler, and all fried items are prepared in 100% peanut oil.

The menu reflects the Mid-Atlantic heritage of its Lancaster County location. The crabcakes are a point of pride: made using back-fin Blue Crab meat following a Baltimore-style recipe traced to BlackJack 'The Pirate,' they anchor the menu as both a sandwich filling and a dinner centerpiece. The kitchen's slow-roasted pulled pork and brisket — available in sandwiches, grilled cheeses, mac & cheese, and stuffed baked potatoes — showcase an equal devotion to low-and-slow barbecue craft.

Jack's is equal parts family restaurant and neighborhood tavern. Soups are offered in fresh-baked bread bowls; the signature Tips Sandwich (Filet Mignon with sauteed onions, mushrooms, and melted American Cheese) became the house's most famous item. From the one-pound Jack the Giant Killer Burger to the humble regular hot dog at $2.95, the menu is built for guests of every appetite and budget.

1location in Millersville, PA
100%peanut oil frying
$$price range

Ready to visit Jack's Tavern?

Find current hours, confirm today's prices, and plan your visit at the official website or call (717) 872-8300.

Visit Jack's Tavern in Millersville, PA
FAQ

Frequently asked questions

What is Jack's Tavern known for?

Jack's Tavern in Millersville, PA is best known for its hand-ground Black Angus burgers (the beef is ground in-house from cuts other restaurants use as steaks), Baltimore-style crabcakes made with back-fin Blue Crab meat, and the signature Tips Sandwich — choice pieces of Filet Mignon with sauteed onions, mushrooms, and American Cheese.

Does Jack's Tavern use peanut oil?

Yes. Jack's Tavern fries all items in 100% peanut oil. Guests with peanut allergies should notify staff before ordering, as cross-contact is possible with any fried item.

What is the cheapest item on the Jack's Tavern menu?

The cheapest item is the Regular Hot Dog at $2.95. Jack's signature Hot Dog is $4.95. A cup of chili or soup of the day (Soup Du Jack) also runs $4.95.

What are Jack's Tavern's most popular dishes?

The most popular items include the Jack Burger 1/2 Lb. ($10.95), the Tips Sandwich a'la Jack ($16.95), the Crabcake Sandwich ($12.95), Super Nachos ($13.95), and Jack's Famous Baked Potato Soup ($8.95). The Tips Sandwich is described on the menu as Jack's most famous sandwich.

Does Jack's Tavern have vegetarian options?

Yes. Jack's Tavern offers several vegetarian-friendly options including the Beyond Veggie Burger ($14.95), Lasagna (meatless recipe, $12.95), Grilled Cheese ($4.95), 5 Cheese Mac n Cheese ($4.95), Tossed Salad ($5.95), Caesar Salad ($8.95), and various bread and cheese appetizers. Ask your server about preparation methods.

What is the Tips Sandwich a'la Jack?

The Tips Sandwich a'la Jack ($16.95) is Jack's signature sandwich and most famous dish. It features choice cuts of Filet Mignon — not sirloin — cooked to order and smothered with melted American Cheese, sauteed onions, and mushrooms on an Italian roll. A plain version (without onions and mushrooms) is available for $13.95.

Does Jack's Tavern have a kids menu or smaller portions?

While Jack's Tavern does not publish a separate kids menu, many dinner entrees are available in smaller portions at reduced prices — for example, the Ham Steak smaller portion is $11.95 (vs. $15.95 full), Grilled Boneless Chicken Breast $13.95 (vs. $17.95), and Calf's Liver $14.95 (vs. $18.95). Ask your server about child-friendly options.

What soups does Jack's Tavern serve?

Jack's Tavern rotates several soups including the famous Baked Potato Soup ($8.95), Baked French Onion ($8.95), house Chili ($4.95 cup / $6.95 bowl), Maryland Crab Soup ($6.95 cup / $8.95 bowl), Beef Stew ($5.95 cup / $7.95 bowl), Shrimp & Corn Chowder ($6.95 cup / $8.95 bowl), and a daily Soup Du Jack. Any bowl can be served in a fresh-baked bread bowl for $2.00 extra.

Where is Jack's Tavern located?

Jack's Tavern (Jack's Family Tavern & Restaurant) is located at 15 South Prince Street, Millersville, Pennsylvania 17551. You can reach them by phone at (717) 872-8300. Check their official website or social media for current hours before visiting.