Menupedia is an independent reference. Not affiliated with any restaurant listed. Menu data reviewed May 2026 — confirm with the official source before ordering.
Menupedia
Bagels · Breakfast · Deli

All Star Bagels Menu Prices 2026: Bagels, Breakfast & Lunch

All Star Bagels in Jackson, NJ has been crafting fresh-baked bagels and hearty sandwiches since 1994. From classic bagels with cream cheese to signature Heavy Hitter breakfast builds and deli lunch subs, everything is made fresh daily at their single Bennetts Mills Road location.

Open 6 AM dailyFresh-baked bagelsBreakfast & lunch
Jump to full menu Cheapest items
Sample · $

Signature items

Bagel with Flavored Cream Cheese$2.70
Bacon, Egg and Cheese$4.25
Philly Cheese Steak Sub$6.00
Dozen Bagels$10.50
Jump to: Quick answers Full menu Cheapest items Most popular Compare prices About FAQ
Quick answers

What to order — at a glance

Cheapest item
Plain Bagel $0.95
Most popular
Bacon, Egg and Cheese on a Bagel $4.25

Classic Jersey deli staple

Best value
Dozen Bagels $10.50
Biggest sandwich
Philly Cheese Steak $6.00
Full menu with prices

All Star Bagels full menu and current prices

Prices reflect the most recently published menu data available online. Verify current prices directly with the restaurant at (732) 276-5217.
Bagels5 itemsHeavy Hitters8 itemsBreakfast Sandwiches10 itemsLunch Sandwiches10 itemsBaked Goods1 itemBeverages4 items
Budget picks

Cheapest items on the All Star Bagels menu

  1. 1Single Bagel$0.95
  2. 2Bagel with Butter$1.90
  3. 3Yogurt Muffin$1.89
  4. 4Bagel with Plain Cream Cheese$2.10
  5. 5Bagel with Flavored Cream Cheese$2.70
  6. 6Egg and Cheese Heavy Hitter$3.25
  7. 7Egg Salad Sandwich$4.50
  8. 8BLT$4.75
Price comparison

Most-ordered sandwiches and their prices

Side-by-side look at All Star Bagels' sandwich lineup from breakfast through lunch.

ItemCategoryPrice
Egg and Cheese Heavy HitterBreakfast$3.25
Bacon, Egg and CheeseBreakfast$4.25
Pork Roll, Egg and CheeseBreakfast$4.25
Western Omelet SandwichBreakfast$5.75
Egg SaladLunch$4.50
Ham and CheeseLunch$5.00
Oven Roast TurkeyLunch$5.00
PastramiLunch$5.50
Roast BeefLunch$5.50
Philly Cheese SteakLunch$6.00
Price comparison

How All Star Bagels prices compare to other bagel and deli spots

Like-for-like comparison of common bagel shop menu categories.

CategoryAll Star BagelsEinstein Bros BagelsNoah's BagelsPanera Bread
Plain bagel (single)$0.95~$1.69~$1.69~$1.39
Bagel with cream cheese$2.10–$2.70~$3.69~$3.49~$3.19
Bacon, egg & cheese sandwich$4.25~$6.49~$6.29~$7.29
Dozen bagels$10.50~$16.99~$15.99N/A
Deli-style lunch sandwich$4.75–$6.00~$7.99~$7.49~$9.49
About

About All Star Bagels

All Star Bagels has been a Jackson, New Jersey institution since 1994, when the family-owned shop first opened its doors at 665 Bennetts Mills Road. Built on the philosophy that fresh is always better, the bakery produces its signature bagels from scratch every single morning — long before most customers have had their first cup of coffee. The shop opens at 6 AM on weekdays and 6:30 AM on weekends, and closes at 12:30 PM once the day's bake is sold out.

The menu is a love letter to classic New Jersey deli culture. Alongside a full roster of freshly baked bagel varieties — plain, sesame, everything, cinnamon raisin, and more — the shop offers a lineup of breakfast sandwiches anchored by New Jersey's beloved pork roll, egg and cheese. The Heavy Hitters section nods playfully to the shop's All Star name, featuring baseball-themed sandwich builds like the Grandslam, the Slider, the Triple Play, and the Designated Hitter. Lunch brings house-made salads, sliced deli meats, and a Philly Cheese Steak that rounds out the midday rush.

Thirty-plus years on, All Star Bagels remains a single-location neighborhood shop — no franchises, no national footprint, just one building where the same dedication to freshness and quality has kept regulars coming back for decades. Catering is available for events, and the restaurant also offers takeout and delivery through third-party platforms for those who want a taste of fresh-baked Jackson bagels without leaving home.

1994year founded
1location (Jackson, NJ)
$price range

Ready to visit All Star Bagels?

Find current hours, confirm today's prices, and place your order by calling the Jackson, NJ location directly.

Visit All Star Bagels online
FAQ

Frequently asked questions

What time does All Star Bagels open?

All Star Bagels opens at 6:00 AM Monday through Friday, and at 6:30 AM on Saturdays and Sundays. The shop closes at 12:30 PM daily — they close when the fresh bake sells out, so arriving early is recommended.

Where is All Star Bagels located?

All Star Bagels is located at 665 Bennetts Mills Road in Jackson, New Jersey 08527. You can reach them by phone at (732) 276-5217.

How much does a bagel cost at All Star Bagels?

A single plain bagel costs $0.95. Adding butter brings it to $1.90, and plain cream cheese makes it $2.10. Flavored cream cheese is $2.70 per bagel. A full dozen bagels is priced at $10.50.

Does All Star Bagels offer delivery?

Yes. All Star Bagels offers delivery through DoorDash and other third-party platforms. You can also call ahead for pickup at (732) 276-5217.

What are the Heavy Hitters at All Star Bagels?

The Heavy Hitters are All Star Bagels' signature breakfast sandwich lineup, named after baseball terms in keeping with the shop's All Star theme. Options include the Grandslam, Slider, Triple Play, and Designated Hitter (each $4.95), as well as build-your-own options starting at $3.25 for an egg and cheese.

Does All Star Bagels have pork roll?

Yes — as a New Jersey deli staple, pork roll (also known as Taylor Ham in North Jersey) features prominently on the breakfast menu. You can order a Pork Roll and Cheese or the full Pork Roll, Egg and Cheese sandwich, each priced at $4.25.

Does All Star Bagels offer catering?

Yes. All Star Bagels offers catering services. Contact the restaurant directly at (732) 276-5217 or through their website at allstarbagels.com to discuss catering options for your event.

What bagel flavors does All Star Bagels carry?

All Star Bagels bakes a variety of classic bagel flavors including plain, sesame, poppy seed, everything, cinnamon raisin, sun-dried tomato, and jalapeño cheddar, among others. The full selection varies daily and is available in-store while supplies last.

How does All Star Bagels compare to national chains like Einstein Bros.?

All Star Bagels offers significantly lower prices than national bagel chains for comparable items — a bagel with cream cheese is $2.10–$2.70 versus $3.49–$3.69 at Einstein Bros. or Noah's. As a family-owned single-location shop that has been baking fresh daily since 1994, All Star Bagels is also widely regarded for the quality of its dough and bake.